Mmm . . . yeah and no.
That scene that I just spitballed up, I can read it off (in realistic character voices) in about 1 minute. And that's with a couple of jokes in there. The cost (in slowing down the movie with tech) is very small to cover one of the movie's biggest plot holes. It's not out of bounds for the franchise at all.
Maybe you'd wanna include another 30-second scene where they are roused from hibernation when they get near Bespin. No need for any real techy stuff there.
It works to explain that Luke was on Dagobah for a while. Otherwise that is not clarified and we don't really see weeks/months worth of activity between him and Yoda. A person who doesn't know SW could watch ESB and think it was a matter of days. It's SW experience/hindsight for us to think it was longer because Luke was established to be so Jedi-like by the early part of ROTJ.
As for it being too much lightspeed tech, I don't see the issue at all. In SW it's established that "jumping to hyperspace' gets you to other planets very quickly. "Sub-light engines" take a long time.
Maybe Han's explanation simply goes: "Well, the Falcon's sub-light engines can get us to Bespin in (insert time here)." That's literally unchanged from the way the movie's logic works now. Those couple of extra sentences about the Falcon's souped-up engines were not critical to the workings of it. I just threw that stuff in there to make it sound like Han Solo talking.
The only tech issue I'm really adding is the concept of emergency hibernation equipment aboard a spaceship. That seems reasonable enough, like a first-aid kit and a life raft on a ship on earth.
Also, it clarifies the idea of human hibernation being possible in SW. That would work forward to help explain to the audience how Han is alive in the carbonite block later. We treat that as a non-issue because we grew up watching movies like this. In 1980 there were probably at least a few more viewers who had a degree of confusion about what was happening when Lando says "He's alive, and in perfect hibernation."
Downside:
If they can use human hibernation in a controlled way for space travel, maybe that takes some of the big-deal out of it. It would make Han's carbonite nap easier to understand but perhaps it would reduce the dramatic punch of it.
Maybe there should have been degrees of it. The Falcon's Bespin trip would be using a light medically-induced coma like they do in real life today. When Han gets carbonited, it would be a scary quasi-death situation.
At any rate, I do think there is value in salting the movie with the idea of a human being 'put to sleep' in some minor way before they do Han's carbon freezing scene. As the movie is now, I've always thought that kinda comes out of left field.
Last edited:
