It definitely would have been a better choice for the movie costume.
In fact, while searching for those images, I stumbled upon pretty much the best fan manipulated image of Cavill as Superman that I've seen... what the fan decided to illustrate is what I would describe as a hybrid costume, a cross between the
Superman Returns costume, and the one from
Superman: Earth One, combining the best elements of both, and chucking out what didn't work well. It looks great...
Classic. Powerful. The right look for the character. Too bad Hollywood can't see that. :unsureWell, in ALMOST every instance. I am a BIG fan of John Byrne's post-Crisis mini-series
Man of Steel and its origin for the Big Blue Boy Scout. As has already been mentioned earlier in the thread...When this movie was first announced, some sites even reported that it would be an adaptation of John Byrne's story, but that later changed. Frankly, I'd rather see an adaptation of
Man of Steel than what we're actually getting. :unsure
Oh and just as a reminder, that whole thing of the S shield being the symbol of the House of El began with
Superman: The Motion Picture starring Christopher Reeve.