Here is a very quick explanation of how I came to the conclusion they were right:
I took this screenshot (same as yours above) along with about 4 others,
and analyzed it this way:
I calibrated my monitor (EIZO).
I did a general color correction based on these sites, to get as close as I could to a basic color that was close to on set using a curves layer. Notice the skin color.
I basically had to average these, as eyes-for example-can change tone in different lights, etc. The highlight on the chair was pretty good, though.
I zoomed in on an area that was the best lit, and noticed it did look red. However, I used the color dropper to measure the color (when a neutral color is near green, we see red like these strawberries which are gray):
Why?
This Picture Has No Red Pixels—So Why Do the Strawberries Still Look Red?
When I measured it, it was actually brown:
Further proof can be seen when you lower the cyan in another curves adjustment layer (red is not touched much, look at the skin):
When you look at the pieces, they are true brown now, without the cyan fooling your brain. Yes, there is less saturated color overall, but you get the point...