Even though the ANH and R1 are in the same time period I'm going to say they are not the same class of ship. There's just too many differences between the two even if they were meant to be the same type of ship.
watch the entire thing... its worth it.
Especially the part where Doug Chaing talks about all the practical effects in The Phantom Menace. More practical effects and real models than in TFA. ;-)
Actually, I can inject what I want -- especially when what I said wasn't a value judgement on the films, but a statement of facts. I didn't tell anyone to like or not like anything. But really, my occasional few pro-PT comments are a drop in the bucket to the PT hate that is often casually injected where IT doesn't belong (maybe you don't see it because you agree with it). The appropriate use of digital effects is absolutely one of the reasons often cited by people who don't like the PT. It's the very reason Disney's marketing pushed so hard on the subject.
Regardless, someone posted a link to a video in this thread. I can comment on it.
I commented about studio models in a model forum. People make asides, jokes, and the occasional off-topic comments all. the. time. Respectfully, it's not your job to police me and, frankly, if my comment wasn't pro-PT I doubt you'd care at all. For some reason, it's VERY important for people who don't like the PT to make sure no one else is allowed to like them either. So maybe that's the issue and not that I strayed briefly off-topic.
But I'll reserve all my comments on this thread exclusively the Z-SD. Fair nuff?
We done?
Hopefully Bandai is aware (and I'm sure they are) of the Zvezda kit and will monitor its sales. I just hope the Zvezda kit does not scare off Bandai into thinking that two large SD's is too much for the market to bear.
At very least it will clearly demonstrate there is a market for this subject.Holy hand grenades! That's it. That's the star destroyer kit we've been drooling for. The only thing better (for me) is if it were the original ANH version. Otherwise, it's a thing of beauty! We'll need to scratch the garbage dump port, but it's a worthwhile omission for getting a styrene 2-footer. Need to start collecting fiber optics and making a lighting plan...