how would they compare to the in-game Journal if the book was one of the 3.5" X 5.5" ones like I'm using?
(I'm still convinced that I have the right size.. even though I DO prefer the larger book)
Well, before I started this project I did several scaling tests on the book.
I found out that there's no way to get the book to one size and make everything inside the book scale to that one size.
For example - On a 5.5"X3.5" book, the coins would look just about perfect.
However, the size of an American passport page is 3.5"X5"...THis would mean that it would be impossible to fit 2 passport pages, side by side, into the smaller Moleskine book.
The passport pages would need be be shrunk considerably in order to fit.
The end result would be a passport page that is about the size of a candy wrapper.
Also, universal size for a business card is 2"X3.5" ...Once again, the business card would have to be shrunk considerably to match the scale of a 5.5"X3.5" book .
The same applies to the postcard with the oil lamp. Standard postcard sizes are 6X4.5" - 7"X5" - 8"X6" - 9"X6"...All are too big to fit into a 5.5"X3.5" moleskine book.
Then there are the shots showing Drake's hands in comparison to the book.
The 8"X5" Moleskine book is a better scaling match than the 5.5"X3.5" book.
The best size for the book would actually be something around 7.5"X"5" tall....Unfortunately I couldn't find a Moleskine style book with that size.
In the end I just decided to choose the size book that best matched the majority of the inserts, so I went with the 8"X5".
DS