I realised that the guy was showing a MR non-functional lightsaber so I altered my comment just a bit, nonetheless ... if you purchase a MR Luke ESB it might still be a little more fat than a real graflex ... as for comparing between the both sabers I can tell you when Lucas was shown Anakin's saber he approved of it being like Luke's while there's a world of difference ... just shows, although GL always has a keen eye for continuity, when the sabers are wielded so fast in battle or just hardly shown being worn, GL was not bothered at all
... also a lot of people who are getting into lightsabers expect them to look prestine when first purchased ... however the real screen-used lightsabers look awefully worn and mostly scratched in real life and that's what makes them great ... for the weathering and used-future appearance ... keep that in mind when gathering vintage parts
Chaim
exactly! thats what i too like about the sabers, obiwans old rusty saber, lukes ESB saber has seen some wear and tear, i LOVE the original saber in the ranch, that is super cool, with all the rusted parts... this is wear the prequel kinda killed it for me, the shiny vintage sabers, with all the gold on them... i understand where GL was aiming at but i just never cared for it...
i am a die hard when it comes to screen used stuff, but its so hard in the starwars movies because there was never really any consistency... which as long as i can make it look like the saber in that one scene, im happy
im shooting for the Lukes ESB saber in the wampa cave... you can see it up close and shes pretty beat
one thing that upset me was in ROTS anikans saber was approved by george but u can clearly see its different! even to my novice eyes i can pick up the differences.... so now its like what happened? did anikans saber break threw the 19 yrs of obiwan hiding? and obiwan fixed it up with spare parts of his own? (the glass calculator bubbles for example)
that stuff erks me lol
- - - Updated - - -
I've always had a hard time with that... before I got into the whole prop world, I was big on restorations. So while I LOVE the look of weathered props, losing that need to have them looking right off the assembly line has been tough.
Thusly my ANH is as close to clean as I could get, while my ESB is allowed to look a little crappy.
I bought a weathered Vader MOM on a graflex reborn that I want to rebuild and re weather (I don't like the black gloss paint currently on it), but I'm also trying to get the rest of the parts to do an "As first built" version on a graflex as well.
i can agree with ya. like lukes ROTJ saber i dont believe should look weathered, it looked pretty clean on scene, and plus in the story it seems he just finished building it from scratch, its weird... i like the ROTJ saber shiny and new, but ep 1-3 i cant get to like
vader on the other hand, in my eyes his should always be clean, with the connections he has and the mechanical ability that thing should always look new! now im just babbling!! lol