Mine arrived in the mail today. Overall I am pleased with the piece.
The aluminum shroud seems very well done and the paint application seems to be the best on the piece overall. The stock and barrel/vent are pretty well made, but the paint application seems extremely thick. I really like these though I wish the paint was applied less heavily on the stock and vent.
The fit and finish of the resin portions are not quite as nice. The detail on the Thompson seems a bit soft in some areas. It also seems that the clean-up was performed somewhat crudely in a few spots prior to their being painted(like they were sanded with 60 grit paper, then painted). The fit of the bolt is loose and floaty on mine. It would be nicer if it was a bit of a snugger fit. Maybe I'm being picky because I'm subconciously comparing it to the superb resin pieces I own which came from Matt. Mine aslo has a few paint chips/flakes right out of the box, which show the
white resin under the
heavy black paint.
Generally speaking I am not a fan of whatever resin it seems places are so keen on using in things sorts of products these days(mass produced prop replicas and busts/maquettes). This isn't just an HCG thing, I know Sideshow also seems to use it in almost everything as well. It just seems cheap and filler heavy, which ultimately makes it hold lousy detail and brittle. Companies could at the very least start tinting the stuff to match some base coat color. For example, black would have been a swell color for the PRs
I don't notice any barrel/SPAS droop on my BB standard PR. So it is either not there or so minimal that I'm not really picking up on it.
Speaking of brown bess, those with actual Humbrol brown bess painted items, how close a match is the HCG color? I've never seen brown bess in person only in photos and wasn't expecting it to be quite so... brown :lol
The magnets are
strong in the mag clip. The first time I inserted the clip it pulled it in so hard it made the darn battery door pop off inside the mag well. Now it is jammed in there somehow and I can't even completely remove the mag to extract it becasue it catches on the jammed door.. I'm going to need to look inside it with a flashlight later tonight and try and carefully use a screw driver or some similar utensil to try and reposition it so I can remove the mag and then extract and the re-attach the battery door.... grrrrr.
Critical comments notwithstanding I don't regret the purchase and feel it is worth the money. It is honestly what I expected at the price point for a mass produced item. If I could have changed anything about the design it would be replacing the resin portions with some sort of higher impact injection molded plastic. That's my practical wish as opposed to it being all metal
The paint chips are minor issues in my opinion. I can easily fix them and I had always planned on weathering the piece once I received it anyway.
- TGM