It's STAR WARS. It's a FANTASY. It's nonsensical to have sound and explosions in space, along with ridiculously-sized ships that are slower in space than smaller ships with smaller engines.
If you are a true Star Wars fan - you accept the nonsensical for what it is and hope that Bandai makes a kit of it.
I am a fan. Just not a fanboy. I dont feel like I must love everything just because it has SW logo on it.
Old EU is a great example. For the most part, it's garbage, but I like few good stories that came from it. And I dont feel like I'm some worse breed of a fan just because I'm more critical about things I love. It's like rising a children, you just cant prise it for everything it does and shut your eyes when it bevahes like a brat, because things just get worse.
Also, there's something like "internal logic" and "suspension of disbelief". Movie doesnt need to be realistic to be believable and enjoyabe, it only needs to keep its internal logic tight. Sequels are good example how to throw logic out of the window and ruin the suspension - let's just mention how Snoke SSD was destroyed or how you can see almost whole upper half of second death star in Rise of Skywalker trailer, desipte seeing it turned into space dust in RotJ.
I guess you forgot that powerful Force users can forsee the future, even if it is always in motion. Palpy knew Luke was going to Vader to try to redeem him. He just did not accurately see the outcome - or - maybe we find out in IX that he did - and all of this was what he intended. Who knows for sure?
that's just guessing for now. Also, that would cheapen Anakin redemption.
The FO may simply have been prep for what Palpy intended to do once his Grand Plan with Rey reached it's fulfillment point. Did you forget that he set up the Separatist Confederacy simply to prime the galaxy for what the Republic would be turned into using their own military? Also- apparently those Destroyers are equipped with shooty cannons ala the Lancer from the bay of the Venator class Destroyer in Sith that are upgraded with bunker busting Death Star tech of some kind.
If he had such powerfull ships at his disposal, then why he didnt use them during civil war? Once again, lack of internal logic.
A trait employed by most despots like Hitler and Pol Pot that would work to destroy their own nation and people for 'failing' and not being worthy enough of their genius and benevolence.
yeah, that quote is straight pararell to hitler last days (chuck wendig just loved to force his political views on everyone in a very straightforward way), but that's exactly what makes this whole "return theory" stupid - if he knew that he will return, why begin everything from scratch? He had powerfull fleet hidden somewhere, why not use it to squash republic? Just to show how evil he is? It worked in hitlers case, because he know he would be dead and nobody would resurect him, but considering SW lore?
Unless we find out that they were intended to be vessels for him to live in forever. That may be the whole reason he created Anakin to begin with. Rey may be Phase II of what he was attempting to accomplish. Vader may have been made a tool because he no longer was a perfect vessel for Palpatine to live in. Palatine may have decided to turn Sith Rule of Two into reverse - and instead of the Apprentice killing the Lord and taking over - the Lord inhabits the body of the apprentice and 'cheats death'.
yeah, that was also done in old EU. But for now, it's just your guess. Maybe you're right, maybe not, but there's a lot of evidence that disney didnt plan anything and just let the directors do what they want. Whole Luke arc was changed at the final edit of TFA, because rian johnson wanted to show him in exactly opposite way that JJ Abrams planned.
Of course Bandai cannot make a kit of those attributes - so while we speculate as to why the thousands of destroyers that make no tactical sense in the story - we hope we get a niceBandai model kit of this Imperial I-Class B - Devastator with super laser.
Well, speak for yourself, because I'm pretty sure that I'm not the only one who thinks that "devastator with super lasers" would be waste of the molds and development time
and that's where our discussion makes circle - maybe I'd think about that devastator differently, if only whole trilogy was prepared better and the ship and it's backstory made more sense in-universe. Being just another slight variation of something decades old also doesnt help, because I'm pretty sure that most people would prefer just regular devastator.