And now the winners of the "2009 $1. Store lightsaber contest."

Re: Voting is here, for the 2009 $1. Store lightsaber contest.

Are any of the makers going to reveal the names and sources of their parts, or is there some weird legality that will get in the way?
 
Re: Voting is here, for the 2009 $1. Store lightsaber contest.

Once the contest is over, I do believe everyone is allowed to spill the beans if they choose to do so.
 
Re: Voting is here, for the 2009 $1. Store lightsaber contest.

VERY difficult to choose just one! That's why I waited five days to cast my vote! I've settled on #4. Great textures and finish, and the parts are not immediately recognizable. Has a nice EU look; I could easily see it in the hand of some alien Jedi.

So many great entries though! I could've easily named a top five instead of just one. Perhaps a "top five" voting system might be a good idea in the future, that way more entries will get votes and no one entry will dominate.
 
Re: Voting is here, for the 2009 $1. Store lightsaber contest.

#2 gets my vote. going for a classic OT saber with limited parts / budget was a tough job, and i think that came out great.
 
Re: Voting is here, for the 2009 $1. Store lightsaber contest.

#15 gets my vote. I love the overall look of that thing. Beautiful work indeed!
All the others are great too by the way. Very creative!
 
Re: Voting is here, for the 2009 $1. Store lightsaber contest.

Damn tough choices! These are great!

#15 gets my vote
 
Re: Voting is here, for the 2009 $1. Store lightsaber contest.

Some really nice sabres, kudos to all participants!

# 7 gets my vote.


Besides,

As far as I understand do we (most members of this board, participants and voters) have an affinity to precision and accuracy - especially regarding the weapon of Force users.

Virtually the entire world, consistently spells the French word sabre correctly as ''sabRE''. Except that is, for the United States. In the USA, sport-fencers know that the word is spelled sabRE, but common convention employs the curious spelling ''sabER'', largely for the curved sword used by US cavalry forces last century. It is a curious linguistic convention that in the USA, virtually ALL French/Latin-derived spellings of this sort have been reversed, such as ''metER'' for metre & ''litER'' for litre, even ''centER'' for centre. Even the British, who have a far greater history of linguistic animosity towards the French, spell gallic words correctly.

Whilst STARWARS *IS* a US funded production, even IT originally spelled the word according to international conventions!

According to published LUCASFILM policy, ONLY the movies themselves, the film novels and the radio-plays are to be considered canonical - and in that order. The first edition of the ANH novel, therefore, is THE most canonical written source available. There, the word is spelled "lightsabre". To date, the only instance of the word "sabre" seen on screen was during the credits to TESB, where it was also spelled sabRE (a reference to the 'sabre system' CGI-FX programme developed by ILM and used for the sword effects onscreen).

Accordingly, why not choose to spell "sabre" according to international-English conventions? If a few less broadly minded fans have a problem with this policy, we can only crave their indulgence.

No offense, just a thought!

Cheers,
Falk

Actually I have seen it spelled Sabre here, and on other forums quite a few times. However, it is not recognized by almost any spell check program over here in the states as being correct. (in fact as I right this I have "spell check" trying to fix my "error")

Plus, though English is said to be the hardest language to learn. (and spell) there are for many things a rather simplistic rules, to help with the bulk of words. For example. "Sabre" Spelled "Saber" in the US would be pronounced with a "Hard A" like you would find in "Make". (witch would be the correct pronunciation for the world.) On the other hand, If you spelled it "Sabre" over here, the majority of people seeing it one the page would pronounce it with a "Soft A" like you would find in "cat". (witch is wrong, and would confuse our poor children. :lol ) Because, by the rules, that many of our words fallow, there would be nothing to make the A in the word "Hard".


In short, you are in fact correct, BUT it just looks very, very, wrong to most Americans, and it is not likely to every change for the majority of us. Sorry about that, and thanks for voting.

Now back to the Voting. :)
 
Re: Voting is here, for the 2009 $1. Store lightsaber contest.

Farmer; One who farms.
Voter; One who votes.
Saber; One who 'sabes'
 
Re: Voting is here, for the 2009 $1. Store lightsaber contest.

Are any of the makers going to reveal the names and sources of their parts, or is there some weird legality that will get in the way?

I have pics of my build and will put up a thread of how I came up with a plan, scrounged the $$ store, drew up a sketch, and built and painted the saber(sabre).
 
Re: Voting is here, for the 2009 $1. Store lightsaber contest.

Actually I have seen it spelled Sabre here, and on other forums quite a few times. However, it is not recognized by almost any spell check program over here in the states as being correct. (in fact as I right this I have "spell check" trying to fix my "error")

Spell check also doesn't detect misused words that sound the same as the intended words.
Such as "right" instead of "write" or "witch" instead of "which".
;)
 
Re: Voting is here, for the 2009 $1. Store lightsaber contest.

#3

I just keep coming back to that awesome emitter assembly.
 
Re: Voting is here, for the 2009 $1. Store lightsaber contest.

We Americans have enough trouble reading as it is. Correct spelling would just confuse people as they wouldn't know how to pronounce it, Saber = "Say Bur" and Sabre = "Say Bree". :unsure
 
Last edited:
Back
Top