Somebody asked if they were going to release the movies individually, and I never saw the answer. Anybody know?
I'd love to buy the full set, but I'm tired of buying a complete new version every few years when the "latest-greatest" comes out. Star Wars and Terminator 2 do the same thing. Yes, the Alien Blu Ray set has some extras that were not on the Quadrilogy DVD set. But in 3 years when SUPER HD (or whatever) comes out, then we'll be going through this again... and they'll dig up some more extras to justify us buying it ALL yet again.
It just gets old and I feel like they try to take advantage of the true fan of these films (be it Alien, Star Wars, or Terminator). The only difference is now, many of us are in poor or unsure financial conditions.
Anyways, I'm guessing after the boxset fervor dies down, THEN they'll release the individual movies. I think they did that with the Quadilogy DVDs. I'm gonna wait for that. Or try anyway.
Ok, I think I can take a dive on this one.
Chris, unlike Terminator 2, this is the first time the ALIEN Anthology is being released on to BluRay, where as T2 was released twice before the one with the goodies was eventually released.
I wouldn't classify this as a double dip either since each film is being remastered and re-transfered to meet the standards of what BluRay is capable of presenting (i.e. 7gig DVD vs. 50g BluRay). This is a completely new set presentation of the movies that hasn't been done before so you will be getting something new.
I also think comparing it to Star Wars is not only an inaccurate comparison, but also a disingenuous one. When the original trilogy was released on DVD, it was released no less than four times. The difference on the discs? Nothing. Oh, they threw in the much asked for unaltered versions on a separate disc in later versions, but were those versions given the same amount of justice that the Special Editions received? No. The fundamental standard for the best DVD presentations has always been using an anamorphic setting for a widescreen release, so that the picture could better fit a widescreen TV without zooming in or stretching the picture which reduces quality. They did not do that with the unaltered versions. Why? I don't know. It's like Lucasfilm deliberately made the original versions inferior to the Special Editions. That is
NOT the case here with the ALIEN Anthology.
As for waiting for a newer format coming out like SuperHD, well, you're screwed. Why?
BECAUSE THAT'S THE COSMIC LAW OF TECHNOLOGY! Everything gets better! So if you're going to wait for something, be sure to know what you're waiting for because no matter what, everything will always get better. Will there be a better release of the ALIEN movies sometime in the future? I hope so! After that maybe? Heck yes! After that? Why not?! Things change, and adapting is never free. If you're happy with your Quadrilogy/Single Movie release, than keep it. It's still one of the best presentations of ALIEN out there, and contains some of the best behind the scenes docs I've ever seen. So if you don't want it, you still have something that looks and sounds fantastic.
And there is nothing wrong with purchasing something again, just as long as the reasons behind the purchase are warranted to your expectations. I literally have an instinctive ability to tell which double dips are worth purchasing and which ones are not, and most of them fall into the 'No Buy" category. This is not a double dip. It's a first time, new format presentation of two of my favorite movies. Will adapting cost me money? Sure, but this meets my standards. New formats are always going to cost money, and they should. But unlike multiple double dips on DVD, there is a ton of new work that goes on in these new sets, both in presentation and bonus features that no doubt took a lot of creative effort to get released. Charles even says that he was able to go back and bring in the material he wanted to showcase from the original Quadrilogy in this new Anthology, and that involves some of the pre-existing material from the Quadrilogy. So even though ALIEN3 is on my most hated movies of all time, the restored documentary is going to almost be worth the price of admission on this new set. That and cocooned Burke.
So will I be buying this set? Heck yes. I have been with the home video department since I was in diapers, and I know when it is time to upgrade and when not to. Holding out till a new format comes around is just a lazy catch22 excuse, because as I've said earlier, there will ALWAYS be newer and better formats. We have till late October, so that's plenty of time to perhaps save up for it's eventual release in a slow easy manner that doesn't hinder the budget. I know since I've been doing just that. And that's for the egg* release!
*Home Theater Forum says that the egg will include a real genuine living face hugger! Hooray! I've always wanted to experience the act of homosexual oral rape from an Alien that leads to birth and my eventual death. It would be so worth it if the chest burster turned out to be a Queen. Best daughter ever!