In my opinion this is one of the most powerful scenes in the show so far, it simply gave me the chills. It shows what an excellent actor Stellan Skarsgård's character, Luthen, has to be to be able to live inside the empire world.
It certainly is. Scenes like this easily fail if the actor doesn't deliver.
And the cleaner, brighter room
hidden from the rest of the dark ship - a symbolic reflection of the character and context.
So far there have been a few scenes where in the hands of lesser talent (...) it would have been easy to go full-cliché.
This one below comes to mind.
It's unimaginable to even begin to think that
those running the other shows have the capacity, will or knowhow to come up with a scene like this one. The writing is award-winning, the pacing is spot-on, no score necessary, no unnecessary camera moves - and Lesser's delivery can't get better than this. Dominance without tyranny. From "Speak!" even before he's entered to room, to "We're done." as he exits, all done without show of force or weakness. Pure, refined authority. To me: it's magic.
On top of that, it would have been mandatory for lesser skilled filmmakers to have him pick sides during that scene, under the guise of "wanting to make sure the audience understands." Skilled filmmakers respect the audience and their capacity to figure things out on their own. And that's why we're benefiting from this level of performance, and why players like Lesser and Skarsgard are in this show.
I wouldn't be shocked if in the near future we would see an interview with KK telling us how "
this was the plan all long." That "
the other shows were meant for a younger audience, and that SW needed more mature content for the fans of the original movie who are now at a different stage in their lives."
I wouldn't care.
All I care about is being entertained.
---
I get that it's not for everyone. There's nothing wrong with pew-pew stuff.
I mostly enjoy Mando. But I also enjoy leaving the screen and thinking about what I just saw, and imagining what else there could be in the Universe. Mando and the other shows don't offer (me) that, and this one does.
If we can have SW content of different flavors, for everyone to enjoy, then we all win.