Images can be deceiving. When I've compared multiple original props together in person right in front of me, the red buttons all seem to match. Obi, Qui, Maul, and others. At maximum, I've seen maybe 20 prequel sabers together at the same moment, and they are all generally the same.
Again, images can be deceiving. Here's a shot of three original props together at the same time and place:
View attachment 1728517
Which of these has a more "candy apple" red button, and which a more muted red? The Qui-Gon certainly appears very bright red. Maybe even that Maul. In truth, NONE OF THEM have bright red buttons, it's just how the image came out after development in Lightroom. ALL THREE have the exact same shade of muted wine red on the button when viewed in person.
Here are some other angles:
View attachment 1728518
View attachment 1728519
You can see the Qui-GOn has a slightly different shade than the Maul and Obi, but is still muted and not "bright red" in appearance. This could be an inconsistent batch of spray, or it may have aged differently than the others, or it may have been a different color of paint originally. But in any case it's still a pretty far distance from the original "shiny red" of the anodized port plug. And I've never seen a prop in person that did appear that way.
Again, in my experience the Rustoleum Claret Wine Satin 334062 is the ideal choice. Your mileage may vary ;-)