Mandalorian Reference Thread

This was posted back in December 2020...

NERF vs REAL:


1642698948359.png


Mr.Moldmaker has a good eye...the complete shape is wrong.Painted ok for a Cosplay I would say...but as a replica..no.
 
I don't usually say this when it comes to the Black Series helmets, but this is quite literally just a toy. Of course they have to make a ton of changes to make it a functioning nerf gun.
Yeah, I honestly think it's a bit odd that people are so bothered by it. It's a toy. I bought one and I love it. Chased my nephews around with it and had a blast.

Criticizing a nerf gun as if it were a $1000 replica is kind of like judging McDonalds as if it were Michelin Star cuisine.
 
Criticizing a nerf gun as if it were a $1000 replica is kind of like judging McDonalds as if it were Michelin Star cuisine.
I expect McDonald's to be McDonald's. That's why I'm going there in a minute, rather than getting takeout from Sogno di Vino. I pre-ordered the Amban after seeing the comparisons. I knew what I was getting. I have the files to 3D print an accurate one. I'm covered both ways. :)
 
Sarah Michelle Gellar (Buffy). She was personally sued by MacDonald's for this ad. They not only sued Burger King but Sarah herself. The little girl. Something about it being the first time one company mentioned the other by name.

 
Sarah Michelle Gellar (Buffy). She was personally sued by MacDonald's for this ad. They not only sued Burger King but Sarah herself. The little girl. Something about it being the first time one company mentioned the other by name.

I don't know that she was sued. She was named in the lawsuit and had to testify and then banned from McDonald's. Probably why she still looks good and is still petite... No super-sizing.
 
I expect McDonald's to be McDonald's. That's why I'm going there in a minute, rather than getting takeout from Sogno di Vino. I pre-ordered the Amban after seeing the comparisons. I knew what I was getting. I have the files to 3D print an accurate one. I'm covered both ways. :)
It seems like the major grief is the butt of the rifle. I wonder if it’s possible to 3D print the butt to fit the nerf gun
 
Sarah Michelle Gellar (Buffy). She was personally sued by MacDonald's for this ad. They not only sued Burger King but Sarah herself. The little girl. Something about it being the first time one company mentioned the other by name.

terrible
 
So I came across this today - and immediately thought of you guys...


Its not perfect - but is pretty cool.

Jedi Dade
 
So I came across this today - and immediately thought of you guys...


Its not perfect - but is pretty cool.

Jedi Dade
Thanks for sharing
 
Alright folks, looking for some help to identify the white case used in TBOBF Ch. 5 aka Mando s3 ep1

Heard some people say it's a Pelican case, but I've looked through all of their products and none of them are a close match. The form factors are closer to the style of some camera cases I've seen before. Does anyone recognize this?

Screen Shot 2022-01-27 at 6.59.08 PM.png
 
So I came across this today - and immediately thought of you guys...


Its not perfect - but is pretty cool.

Jedi Dade


It's more accurate in scale than the Nerf version, but the parts are just 3D printed and not very well. You can see definite print lines. Also, in the video he admits that if the prongs are bumped into something with enough force they'll break and he shows it getting bumped into a door that wasn't all that hard and they did break. The prongs look way too big to me, but I haven't actually compared it to any screenshots.
 
A lot of people are saying this is a Palmer Cap-Chur dart gun. Unfortunately, the whole fanbase is very incorrect... I'm not certain what it is exactly, but it has to be a .22lr target pistol something like a High Standard or Colt Match. I KNOW I've had this exact grip in my hands before, but I can't remember what exactly it was (I'm a gunsmith by trade, and I own my own gun shop; I know I've had one of these in-hand before, but I can't place it). I know it's a 70's-80's .22lr target pistol, but which one alludes me.

The grip angle and screw location are the only things correct when comparing it to the Palmer Cap-Chur; the trigger, trigger well, beavertail on the grips, etc. etc. etc. are all wrong when comparing the screenshots to the purported source item.

Unless the prop department at Mando took only the grip panels from the Palmer (and then, at that, edited them severely), there's no way this is a Palmer Cap-Chur....
 
I'm a gunsmith by trade, and I own my own gun shop
I may need to talk to you about some nerdy custom orders and gunsmithing work... ;)

A lot of the things you can find on Etsy and similarly offered through vendors who 3D print things... Well, ya really need to vet them. A friend has gotten both an E-22 and a Naboo S5 from Etsy vendors. The E-22 was a print of Sean Fields' files (I know, because I have them), and it's, in plain language, a shitshow. All PLA, the settings weren't dialed in as there were a few gaps and several pieces with bad layer adhesion, the scope had gotten jarred during printing and had a 1mm offset about halfway up, several pieces arrived broken, some weren't there at all, and it was printed with enough layer height that some detail was lost and there were SOOOOOO many print lines to sand and fill.

We've put many hours into it and it's starting to look decent, but I had to print/reprint some of the missing pieces, tossed the Hengstler and T-tracks and used my own, and had him order a real tac light and picatinny rail. Overall, it would've been cheaper for him, in materials and time, to have me print a kit for him, from the same files, in all-black PET-G (oh, yeah, the filament colors are all over the place, too) at finer resolution and ensuring no misprints. I'd still have used real T-track and accessories, but would've saved him the time he spent trying to sand, fill, and glue all the broken and low-res stuff.

The S5 is just a travesty, front to back. I can't even.

I got a good live-action Westar-35 off Etsy, but I did my homework and went with a good vendor. I'm still making a couple of my own, though, from modded airsoft pistols. This one was for a friend. For an Amban rifle, I'd definitely do as I did -- vet good, accurate 3D files and print it oneself, with good internal support (Sean, for instance, designs his blaster files to work with scaffolds of PVC pipe). I'm working on some FIrst Order stuff right now, and, except for the aluminum "holster" plate and the incredibly fiddly main sight piece, my SE-44C is all printed by me on a simple Prusa i3 with PET-G at 0.2mm layer height. Low and slow gives minimal post-processing and a nice sturdy prop:

SE-44C parts.jpg


SE-44C test assembly.jpg


I have since ground away that stubborn support inside the trigger guard, and the layer bands where the holes are on the flash hider took a bit of glazing putty, but the rest of this is after about an hour of sanding. There's not really any excuse any more for shoddy 3D prints.
 
Back
Top