Solo4114
Master Member
COD4 wasn't longer than 8 hours and people don't complain about that game. Most FPS games are not much longer than 8-10 hours. They are not RPG's. But they make up for it in the hundreds of hours you can spend playing multiplayer. A good satisfying campaign is more important than just making it long for the sake of being long.
Minor caveat: I haven't played any Halo game all the way through, and have only played Halo 1 at all.
That said, I agree that "long for the sake of being long" is a drag. The game needs to feel like the length of it is flowing naturally, rather than being FORCED into being longer through ******* "ride on rails" missions or whatnot. One of the things that initially impressed me about Halo 1 was how open the world felt. I've heard from friends that changed somewhat in subsequent games.
On the other hand, if the story is one of the driving factors of Halo (because, frankly, Deathmatch and Team Deathmatch bore me to tears), it'd be...unfortunate to have an abbreviated campaign or a campaign that feels "artificially" lengthened by goofy missions. Other game series (the old Medal of Honor games, for example) don't really give a crap about their single player portion. Some care quite a bit, but approach "story" from a more "watch stuff happen around you" perspective a la Half-Life 2. Personally, I never felt like the Half Life games had much of a story at all, but they had some cool action set-pieces for various levels. That, however, doesn't equal a story. If Halo has built its reputation on an engaging story, though, then giving players short shrift on that score strikes me as a bad move.
I gather, however, that this is the new paradigm in gaming: give people a short SP campaign, then release additional pay-to-play content after the fact. The gaming mags, all flush with "pretty graphics" overload, ignore this or gloss over it or say "But it doesn't really matter because the MULTIPLAYER..." But to me, it sucks. I know I'll sound like an old fart, but in my day, the SP game still counted.