Ok. Finally took a pic of my McFly ES:
It's a Limited Edition (they sold out in early 2014) 2013 Epihone ES-335 Pro. Most ES-335's have simple "dot" inlays/fret markers and minimal binding, with none on the neck. The Limited Edition Pro has aged/cream binding, coil-tap pickups, vintage tuners, and block inlays. It's pretty much an Epiphone replica of a 1963 Gibson block-inlay ES-335.
So here's what it get's right and wrong. The following info can also serve as a guide to others.
• Guitar model: The original was a Gibson '57-ish ES-345 mono (not stereo). Mine, as already mentioned above, is a 2013 Epiphone ES-335 Pro.
• Headstock shape: Should be Gibson, but instead mine is Epihone's slightly different headstock shape.
• Brand name on headstock: Should be "Gibson" but says "Epiphone" since that's what it is.
• Headstock logo inlay: Should be pineapple logo, and it is since Gibson owns Epiphone and allowed them to use it on this guitar.
• Truss rod cover: Should be black with no engraved writing present. Mine has it's model name, "ES-335 PRO", engraved in white as do most limited or special edition guitars. I don't plan on changing this.
• Tuners: Should be vintage style green plastic "tulip" tuners, and they are.
• Neck: Should be 24.75" scale, and of the set-neck (glued-in) construction type, as opposed to bolt-in (like some replicas such as the Oscar Schmidt OE30CH), and mine is correct.
• Neck binding: Should be present (missing on many ES-335 "dot" models), and it is.
• Fretboard inlays: Should be split parallelograms; mine are small block (as opposed to the large-block inlays on ES-355s).
• Body Shape: Should be the accurate ES body shape (no deformed (too rounded or too pointy) horns), and it is since Gibson owns Epiphone and allows them to use the accurate shape, mine is.
• Body color: It should be translucent red stain (not almost solid so that the wood grain doesn't show and it looks almost like red paint), and mine is.
• Body wood grain: It should run vertically (with the guitar viewed standing up) as one piece (not be of the "flamed" variety where two symmetrical pieces of veneer are used with a seam down the middle and the wood grain running horizontally), and mine does.
• Body clear coat: The body should have a near-gloss finish (not satin or aged), and mine does.
• Hardware color: Gold, though the pickups should appear silver with the gold rubbed off. My hardware, including the aftermarket Bigsby, is all nickel silver, as I prefer that look to gold.
• Stop piece: The guitar should have come originally with a Tune-O-Matic stop piece that was removed and the large screws that originally secured it left in. Mine originally came with the Tune-O-Matic, and when the Bigsby was swapped in I left the large Tune-O-Matic screws in place for that screen-accurate look.
• Vibrato: The vibrato should be a Bigsby unit, the B7 (made-in-the-USA) model. Alternatively the overseas-made "licensed" version of the B7, the B70, could be used with only a small decrease in accuracy. Mine has the B7, though as with all of my other hardware, in nickel silver as opposed to the accurate gold plating.
• Knobs: Their should be two volume and two tone knobs, of the black "top-hat" "gold reflector" variety. Mine are the correct shape and are reflectors (my ES-335 Pro didn't come with these—I had to swap them in), but the reflectors are silver-topped to match my choice of nickel silver hardware. When swapping out knobs, you must take care to note that the knob posts for genuine Gibsons are a different diameter than those for guitars made in Asia, including Gibson's own Epiphone Asian guitars.
• Pick Guard: This should be the short-style black/white 5-layered Gibson-shaped pick guard that ends parallel to the bottom edge of the bottom pickup, not the longer style guard that ends parallel to the stop bar.
• Varitone: Gibson-made ES-345s came with a 12-position tone control dial called a "Varitone" switch. This switch and circuitry should be present. The dial bezel should be gold with black writing, or silver if you (like me) have chosen to go with silver hardware. While aftermarket Varitone dials and circuitry are readily available, gold bezels are not. I have chosen not to fit a Varitone switch to my guitar.
• Strap: This should be in brown leather, and 1" width, with a belt-buckle style length adjustment. I went with a slightly wider 1.5" strap for comfort.
• Upper strap mounting point: This should be installed in the REAR of the body behind the top horn, not on the outer edge of the top horn as is done on some replicas. Mine has this.
I think that's it. As you can see, my guitar has its own inaccuracies, but I love it. I hope the above info is helpful to those evaluating certain guitars to decide if they are accurate enough for you and what things may need to be upgraded. If anyone sees any inaccuracies in what I've written above, please let me know.