EKF5
Active Member
Except at the time Diana makes her wish, she has no idea that the wish stone does anything. It's just an idle wish. She isn't cheating, she's being hum,an. The same goes for the first wish by Barbara Minerva. Neither of them knew anything about the powers of the wish stone. Therefore, the entire opening sequence is meaningless.
I agree completely that neither knew anything about the stone being real. Further, there was no way for them to know the wishes had consequences. (Separate issue that Diana, who owns a magic item, would ever risk making a wish like that while holding an item that says it grants wishes. She should know better.)
I was suggesting that within the structure Jenkins set up the existing magic of the stone and lasso could have been used to better effect from a writing perspective and be joined to the narrative thread that started with the flashback. It would have tied up some loose ends (ok, sorry that wasn't really necessary).