To preface this, much like
Halliwax, I've never been a huge Boba Fett fan. Don't get me wrong, I've always thought he looked cool and he certainly always piqued my interest, but he served his purpose in the OT and at this point it feels like he's overstayed his welcome. I love good well written characters and I find Din Djarin to be a much more compelling character, so this show has a lot to prove that the OG-Mandalorian-who-now-feels-like-he's-playing-catch-up-to-his-superior-copy is worth caring about.
That being said, this first episode was a big disappointment, nothing remarkable. A lot of how I feel has already been said here so I won't retread, however I had a couple major gripes I haven't seen discussed much yet.
The first being
where's the hook? Why is Boba Fett suddenly taking interest in becoming the next crime lord? What's the reasoning? What are his motives/endgame? Also he keeps talking about doing things "differently" but we really have no idea what things were like before he decided to take over the throne, so there's nothing to compare it to and it ends up feeling empty. An opening episode for a show should hook the audience with an interesting dilemma or premise, but this felt void of that. I don't know any more about what this show is than I got from the trailers.
The second thing, and possibly the more frustrating for me...
this episode looked awful. I had the same issue with Mando season two's 'The Tragedy,' it looked cheap and felt like a fan film. In this episode the lighting is flat, the colors feel blown out, and it lacks any interesting cinematography. In terms of direction, the choreography feels soft and lifeless especially, an issue 'The Tragedy' actually didn't have. I'm assuming most of this can be attributed to Robert Rodriguez's directing, which after his 2 episodes of Star Wars I can confidently say I am not a fan. But, I can't overlook that it is likely a mix of him and the DP David Klein, who was the cinematographer for both his episodes. What worries me is Klein is attached to 5 of the 7 episodes, so we'll see how much changing up the directors actually affects the look of the show. Maybe I'm just incredibly spoiled by Dune, but they need to take some notes on how to shoot desert environments in the blazing sun and make them look absolutely breathtaking. Overall, this felt like a huge step down in quality from both seasons of The Mandalorian, which were generally gorgeous.
Last note for now, and related to above, is The Volume is not doing any favors for open desert environments here. For half of this episode the set was clearly a flat floor covered in sand with giant LED screens behind them 'extending' the embarrassingly small stage footprint. This was especially noticeable when Fett has the little tussle with the Tusken guy at night after he runs away and he gets his ass kicked (again). Would it kill them to place the Tusken camp in some rock formations instead of the open "dunes" so they can hide the limitations of The Volume a little better?
Anyway, leading up to this show I didn't care much for Fett and I'm hoping the show will convince me why I should. Jury's still out on that one, but as of now I care less about him than I did last week.