I feel like some people are grossly unaware of the price modded V2s were going for if $600 for a pair of shoes is some astronomical price.
There's a reason why our little group that was so unified before is now fractured and seems more combative. It's a little thing I think I'll call the Completion-Divergence Paradox, and it's something that happens with ALL props eventually.
The CDP is essentially this: when there are no good replicas on the market, then whatever is out there will do because we're all suffering together. So because of that, we deal with "good enough."
Then, either more details are discovered or a newer, more accurate replica comes out, which gets us used to the idea of choice. We become more aware of the differences between versions of the prop and its replicas, and for the first time we are not all suffering together. "Close enough" is no longer good enough, and people attempt to get even closer.
As luck would have it there is usually another round of improvements or discoveries which again fractures the group. Now you have three different tribes, and a replica approaching 100% accuracy, but by this point, everyone has dug into the details, has a favorite version of the prop, has a favorite replica, so if a final replica is 95% accurate, moving 1% closer to someone else's ideal moves the percentage 1% AWAY from your ideal.
Now this movement is barely noticeable when dealing with replicas in the 50-75% accurate range and below because you're still nowhere near complete accuracy. However when you can see the finish line in sight and every detail matters, you suddenly start to keep score. For every point another tribe gets, you feel like you've lost one.
You can watch this cycle happen with everything. Kylo Ren helmets, Star-Lord Blasters, and the grand daddy of the all: Vader helmets!
Sure, when nothing on the market is perfect, using a voice changing Kylo helmet is celebrated. If you used one after The Rocketeer's first run, you'd get looked at funny. Now with another run and a MUCH more accurate helmet being put out, people who have the voice changer are looked at sideways and suddenly the discussion of "idealized" versus "screen accurate" comes into play.
Star-Lord Blasters saw the pattern follow: 3D printed inaccurate run, Nerf gun repaints, scratch replica runs.
And Vader helmets saw the dissection and discussion of everything from peculiarities of the asymmetry to the C-scar, to the two-tone paint job, to the idealized Sith bucket...and these battles will continue forever. But when the first replica helmets came out, everyone was just a kid again, enjoying the joy of getting close to an ideal. But the problem with an ideal is that it is almost never achievable... and that's sort of the place where we are all spinning our wheels.
The same people who said "I'd gladly pay $500 for a 90% accurate shoe" are now saying that this 95% accurate shoe should be $250 before they buy it.
The same people who were happy with the original V1 K-Mags, now won't be happy until some feature seen in a frame or two of the movie appears on these.
The same people who wished they would make a non-electronic version are now bemoaning that the electronics are inherently fragile.
We didn't realize it, but we were lucky that our little community went for so long without any Mag replicas. Before Mark Poon's run, we were all merely unified in our love of a prop. Now look at us...
Just a little food for thought.
-Nick