Check out Being Elmo. Whether you are a muppet fan or just want to feel good about a person reaching their dreams, you'll love it.
Not Netflix, but on Hulu Plus is "The Booth at the End" which is a cool miniseries. It's about a guy in a diner people go to when they need things. They ask for something, anything, and he tells him what he needs them to do in order for what they want to come true. Sometimes he asks them to do something helpful for other people, sometimes he asks people to do terrible things. The story involves about 8 people who go to him, and their stories become intertwined at times and at others remain entirely separate. It remains ambiguous even through the end of what he knows, or how he does what he does, and it's best that way.
Watched this over the last two nights based on your recommendation and the description. Gotta say that it was fantastic. I love the characters and how they justify what they're doing to get what they want. Love the "Man" too. Looks like there is going to be a second series... I want to see how he pulls off the last "deal". They are only 20 minutes long, so it's easy to catch all 5 episodes in one setting.
Shameless
You might want to check out Norwegian Ninja if you haven't seen it yet.
I tried Supernatural, and just couldn't stomach it after the third episode. The leads are way too one-dimensional and cookie cutter.
They do develop a bit more dimensionally as the series goes on. Dean was a bit too much the first season, but he really develops as things go on. The first season is a bit hammy too, until they get into the real meat of the Yellow Eyed Demon story arch. Really once they hit season two they really get a nice stride going and have some really fantastic mythology. It's worth hanging in there until they get going, really.
They do develop a bit more dimensionally as the series goes on. Dean was a bit too much the first season, but he really develops as things go on. The first season is a bit hammy too, until they get into the real meat of the Yellow Eyed Demon story arch. Really once they hit season two they really get a nice stride going and have some really fantastic mythology. It's worth hanging in there until they get going, really.