According to what? I'm not a particularly avid reader of she hulk comics, but from everything I've read she seems to be similarly competent and knowledgeable and a little bit smarty-pants, complete with 4th wall breaks.
This reads a bit condescending dude. Can't help but picture you adjusting your monocle and twisting the tips of your 'stache.
Moon Knight was great. The character blacks out when another personality takes over, and part of the fun was the discovery of the 3rd personality by the end. Again, maybe it wasn't for you, but that didn't make it crap.
Accoding to what? According to her looong history established in the comics. The point of the series is to bring a comic book characrer to life, Right? Was she advertised as "not to be confused with the She-Hulk from the comics" ?
But you admit you didnt really folliw the comics.
And I get it, you just want to be entertained,
...but I dont think you know what "condescending" means.
You just admitted to not really reading the comic, but then want to tell simeone who *has*, that because she checked certain superficial boxes, it is fine.
Um...well no, not if you care about continuity. Not if you actually *read* the comics. If yiu have seen and read what she did in prior, similar situations. Where else are followers of a *comic* character going to establish "continuity" other than from her comics?
Which you haven't really read.
People who actually read alot of her comics, who bought first issues when they came out, are telling you that her behaviour in the series is not She-Hulk. This has been discussed repeatedly in this thread, but then you and some others (repeatedly) toss that information aside and claim that isn't an issue.
....that is not how "continuity" works.
"But she broke the forth wall"You say.
So what?!?! That is a shallow idea of the character. So, as long as she "breaks the forth wall," it iis all good?!?!
"She's a party animal!"
Not really, she drinks herself stupid because she is so miserable.
The series took a great character and made her sad. Really, truly, honestly, it made her sad.
I could go on, but I covered this in my Strong Woman Attorney, Green and Alley McHulk posts.
The "condescending" part are the people who have no real knowledge base to decide how the character *should* behave, yet even after being provided examples of how she handled situations in the comic vs the show, think the fans who'd like some continuity are being "condescending."
...you didnt really follow her in the comics.
And YES Moon Knight was absolutely the laziest series Marvel has put out. Love it all you like, but having people "black out," because the writer knows he can create *ANY* situation and have the character "resolve by blackout" is vacuous.
