Death Star Plans

Ok so taking all of the suggestions into account I came up with this design. I feel that I'm fairly close to the screen prop now. There are a few lines that I added based on the flow of the design they are all lines that could be there based on lighting and shadow etc. So I think i'm getting closer.

This design takes the IBM hard drive into account as the inspiration. So if someone handed me a harddrive and said make something cool that looks like this I feel like this would be close to how I would build it, taking into account all the screen grabs we have.

Screen%20Shot%2009-08-16%20at%2012.01%20PM.JPG


Comparison of some of the hidden lines because of lighting and angle

hiddenedges.jpg
 
dude, holy crap that looks almost dead on!

The only thing that stands out to m is the difference in the "gap" thickness of the upper ring.
Untitled.jpg
 
This looks "fan"tastic. We will now probably be disappointed with the real thing. I still have one issue which is based on the way I built the digital scaffolding around the photos and so it may be an issue of perspective and distortion. I am looking for someone to show me my error. When I mark the straight edges of the lower disk. I can then draw parallels lines along the edges of the raised center section I call the read/write head. This I have been calling a "rectangle" perhaps it is more accurately a parallelogram but I still "see" parallel lines. This also makes the top edge of this "parallel" section end before reaching the top disk so there is a clipped off gap This is the only variance I can see with all of the photo evidence thus far.
 
Bluerealm, you have captured the front form perfectly -- As for the back side take a look at the following image:

Data tape Back side.png
A good portion of the rear section of this drive outline seems to fit some of the brief views we've had so far.

Again, Excellent work.

Oslm
 
This looks "fan"tastic. We will now probably be disappointed with the real thing. I still have one issue which is based on the way I built the digital scaffolding around the photos and so it may be an issue of perspective and distortion. I am looking for someone to show me my error. When I mark the straight edges of the lower disk. I can then draw parallels lines along the edges of the raised center section I call the read/write head. This I have been calling a "rectangle" perhaps it is more accurately a parallelogram but I still "see" parallel lines. This also makes the top edge of this "parallel" section end before reaching the top disk so there is a clipped off gap This is the only variance I can see with all of the photo evidence thus far.


Can you mock up a picture of what your talking about? I'm having a hard time seeing what you mean. Use a photo editing tool and mark it up in red.
 
Another change i'm making is the two little rectangles. If you view this gif you can see her leg all the way through them. I orginnally thought they were little barcodes or something but looks like they are rectangle holes all the way through.

rogue-one.gif


Screen%20Shot%2009-08-16%20at%2002.31%20PM.JPG
 
Another change i'm making is the two little rectangles. If you view this gif you can see her leg all the way through them. I orginnally thought they were little barcodes or something but looks like they are rectangle holes all the way through.

https://fsmedia.imgix.net/dc/8a/cb/....gif?rect=58,0,524,262&dpr=2&auto=format&q=75

http://cdn.bluerealmstudios.com/Downloads/RPF_PICS/Plans/Screen Shot 09-08-16 at 02.31 PM.JPG
Sorry, but I don't think they are holes. Looking at the footage again they are as reflective as the discs.
 
Sorry, but I don't think they are holes. Looking at the footage again they are as reflective as the discs.

Also they reflect as the face is tilted sunward and not at other times so I tend to agree with LRZ.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
what if it turns out this thing is just a space pizza box?

Rebels gotta eat.

This would be awesome. I always wanted to know how my pizza would arrive in a galaxy far far away long ago.

:)

- - - Updated - - -

what if it turns out this thing is just a space pizza box?

Rebels gotta eat.


This could also be a decoy, plans elsewhere, etc.


Blue Realm your work on this is incredible!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Sorry, but I don't think they are holes. Looking at the footage again they are as reflective as the discs.


Yeah me and trooper_trent were going back and fourth on it. I can see how it could be either.. To me I can see her pant leg through the right side hole. With the brightness all the way up and zoomed super close in.





Screen Shot 09-08-16 at 03.57 PM.JPGScreen Shot 09-08-16 at 04.00 PM.JPG
 
Last edited:
Yes, your last version looks correct to me. It was the version stamped "Screen Shot 09-08-16 at 01.33 PM 001.JPG" which did not look correct to me. You may have made changes or you may have just changed the perspective on the same design. If it was just a change in your angle of presentation then I need to do a little more work on my side to improve my analysis. Thanks for your consideration on this minor point.
 
One more tough one to go. I took some direction from @olsm and thought about hard drive internals. I did not do any detailed research as I did not want that to bias what the photos were showing me. Like last time my diagram is just to continue the discussion. I do not have any special insight.

View attachment Subway Front.pdf
 
Back
Top