Saw it yesterday, really enjoyed it.
I'd give it a B+ (8/10).
Some awesome moments, CMs "transformation" scenes were wonderfully done, a rare combination of power and visual beauty that really moved me, for reasons I don't really get. They just did.
Brie made a strong impression on me as CM,so I don't understand many of the critics complaints. Compared to the likes of Jason Bourne (the same kind of memory loss flashbacks), she was way more lively and engaging, even as "Vers". I get she was nowhere near as sympathetic as Dianas WW, but she is a very different character. A couple of moments felt written a little off for her, but as she recovered her memories of Carol Danvers she became more as I imagined she should be ,and the flashbacks made total sense to the story. I really don't see how they were a problem either.
Her buddy relationship with Nick Fury was great fun (the "deaging" was so astonishingly brilliant you just ended up NOT noticing it !!!) though again there were a couple of moments I felt were poorly done for him, not too many, but it jarred with the character. On the whole it was another very enjoyable MCU team up.
And kudos to the VFX teams again. Maybe because my cinema has had a new upgrade but CM looked , with certain exceptions, great ,particularly the space craft battles. A few too many scenes for my liking were shot with an excessive degree of that "Solo" darkness which made it difficult to easily see what was going on, but it wasn't a fatal flaw, just occasionally annoying.
I was pretty surprised by the choice of what they did with the Skrulls and I'm not too certain how that will work out going forward. But I very much preferred this version of how Carol was transformed into CM, because of what is likely to come in "Endgame" it actually made alot of sense. Given how Thanos absolutely wipes the floor with the Avengers at the end of "Infinity War" they are going to need an edge, and I think done this way, the CM / T link will provide that without going too far.
There was one terrible use of a soundtrack song ( and overall the songs used weren't that great) during the end space fight , I didn't like how Fury lost his eye,and the idiotic Poe Dameron /Jude Law confrontation at the end lost making it a total "A" grade for me, but only just. It was still a very enjoyable and strong Marvel movie, and I thought a great introduction for CM into that universe..