Fire up this old thread, lol
I just got the Abby Shot version today. I own 2 (formerly 3) authentic WWII RAF Officers Greatcoats to compare with. These are my observations:
The color is spot on to the real thing, but Jacks looks to be a bit bluer (at least on Miracle Day). That could be any number of things like lighting, post coloration, different coats, etc. but my AS and original match. Also the AS has a great feel to it, similar to the high end tailored coat I have made with very smooth wool.
The repro is much lighter (as I had hoped) and had a share of wrinkles out of the bag, The original will Not wrinkle, it's too thick and heavy, I guess.
The epaulets, as noted, are way off. Nearly an inch short and a bit thin. Also, the belt is easily 17" too long. I'm talking about a medium size coat. It actually fits me quite nicely over all. I may do what the other poster did and take the belt down to the correct size and use the ample remainder to replace the epaulets. (I believe he had an extra belt to work with, but there is loads of extra length to work with).
I have already purchased the proper rank ribbon to replace the poor reproduction on here. And I'm looking for authentic buttons and Belt Buckle. Speaking of buttons, it's hysterical to see where they placed the top set.. They should be placed so the collar can be buttoned all the way up...not even close. I'll soon sort that out as well.
Overall, as a long coat, I like it more than I had expected. It is well made, I like the material inside and out. And It fits longer on me than I thought. Fantastic!
Eventually I could follow up with pictures if there is any interest.
Meanwhile, if anyone can point me to an authentic buckle and/or buttons, it will be greatly appreciated