Hahahahaha!
Poor DC. Avengers destroys NY, we love them. Nobody will call out Iron Man on fighting Hulk and ruining the city in Avengers 2. But Supes destroys Metropolis, we loathe him. Daredevil goes dark as hell, we praise their new grit. Superman goes dark as hell, we act like we're watching an "I love the 90s" special mocking goths (and wait, don't we all love the Crow?) Starlord kills the crap out of people, we cheer. Supes or Batman maybe kill someone? Our fingers start wagging and we break out the lecture on "heroes don't kill." I admit, DC has made some missteps (Green effing Lantern comes, sadly, to mind) but jeez.
You want a heroic Superman that hearkens back to the glory days of Reeve? Superman Returns is your movie. Oh wait, EVERYONE HATED THAT.
Sigh.
You're missing the point.
With the exception of Batman, DC heroes are GODS. They're infallible.
My earliest recollection of Superman was an old black-and-white serial I saw at my local theater when I was 3.
Clark Kent swerved off the road and crashed his car into a tree to avoid hitting a skunk that was crossing the road.
And in the George Reeve series (which I also grew up on) - Superman knew he was indestructible. Nobody could hurt him.
Empty your gun at him - you're not gonna hurt him. He knew that, and used it to his advantage.
He'd just let you shoot all your bullets, then he'd wrap a steel I-beam around you and wait for the cops to show up.
The Superman I grew up with wouldn't level an entire city block to kill (KILL!) one badguy.
He would have manipulated the fight into an unpopulated area, then wrapped the guy in a steel I-beam and waited for the cops to show up.
You want dark heroes?
That's why there's Batman.
Superman is supposed to represent what's RIGHT. Not what's GREY.
That's why my generation has a problem with Zach Snyder's Superman.
Superman doesn't make mistakes. Superman ALWAYS does what's right.
That's the whole point of Superman.
It makes me kinda sad that there's a whole generation of kids who won't accept good for the sake of good -
They have to have a psychologically troubled hero.
Like I said, that's why there's a Batman.
Let Batman be Batman, and let Superman be Superman.
If Superman isn't "dark" enough for you, then read Batman.
I don't know what else to say about this. You kids obviously just don't get it.