Old but fun thread. Just to name things that could potentially be within my reach but simply don't seem to exist (as opposed to the usual oversized, or prohibitive stuff like a DeLorean or the Ark of the Covenant):
- Daniel Dravot's crown, pendant and golden arrow from The Man Who Would Be King.
- A wood-carved Arumbaya fetish from Tintin's The Broken Ear.
- A metal replica of Nathan Drake's astrolabe from Uncharted 3.
- The faun's bone flute and dagger from Pan's Labyrinth.
- Eowyn's helmet from The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King.
- The war bonds style Rita Vrataski's 'To Victory' poster from Edge of Tomorrow.
- One-Eyed Willy's Skull from The Goonies (this is the only one on the list I've seen available as a replica, but never truly screen accurate, bandana and all).
If anyone knows where to find any of these things, feel free give me a shout.