JMO
Active Member
I have been looking for Rick's watch and of course the KC3584 is going for a fortune but in looking I found that there are 2 watches that look virtually identical.
The KC 1351 and KC3584. (1352 and 3585 are the same but with dark faces in case you want to make your own replica without the expense which I will be trying)
Here are 2 that are currently being sold side by side with and a shot of the backing for the model number. 1351 on the left, 3584 on the right.
One is "New York" the other is "REACTION"

I have checked and can't find any thread to say that the 3584 was actually confirmed off the screen used watch or just that it was what it looks like. I found both these models in various searches they have some with "New York" and some with "REACTION".
The original ads for the 1351 have leather bands but the faces are correct and have both New York and REACTION too.
Also it looks like the New York is brushed or stainless and the REACTION is polished or chrome...

Both 1351 and 3584 are advertised to have 38mm housings.
I compared the photos of the screen watch to both face styles and I would say that the screen one is a "New York" not the "REACTION" watch.


Can anyone clarify?
If people are laying out big coin we should at least know its the right watch!
(PS the ladies model is KC4480 and the ads say the housing is only 28mm wide just fyi)
The KC 1351 and KC3584. (1352 and 3585 are the same but with dark faces in case you want to make your own replica without the expense which I will be trying)
Here are 2 that are currently being sold side by side with and a shot of the backing for the model number. 1351 on the left, 3584 on the right.
One is "New York" the other is "REACTION"

I have checked and can't find any thread to say that the 3584 was actually confirmed off the screen used watch or just that it was what it looks like. I found both these models in various searches they have some with "New York" and some with "REACTION".
The original ads for the 1351 have leather bands but the faces are correct and have both New York and REACTION too.
Also it looks like the New York is brushed or stainless and the REACTION is polished or chrome...

Both 1351 and 3584 are advertised to have 38mm housings.
I compared the photos of the screen watch to both face styles and I would say that the screen one is a "New York" not the "REACTION" watch.


Can anyone clarify?
If people are laying out big coin we should at least know its the right watch!
(PS the ladies model is KC4480 and the ads say the housing is only 28mm wide just fyi)