The Walking Dead Season 4

Kerr Avon said:
Did you not watch the show? Rick isn't going to lie to the rest of the group. If he did, and it ever came out, his credibility would be shot. Carol didn't really deserve any protection at that point from him. Carol had done exactly what Shane had done with Otis. She killed those two people with the idea it'll save her life. She chose to take their lives to enhance her chance of survival, period. The moment she did that, she had to go, one way or another.
Click to expand...

I did watch the show and understand how two face Rick is. Riceball did a great job at summing it up.
 
I wouldn't want to have to worry that every time I sneeze, Carol is going to sneak in during the night and stick a knife in the back of head.
 
Although for everyone wondering about Daryl's reaction, he did say something along the lines of thie to Tyreese "...whoever did this, we'll find them and put a bolt in there head..."

Not sure ultimately how sympathetic he may be when he finds out actually who it was. I'm guessing he may be on the same page as Rick with this one. Herschel is probably with Rick as well considering he's risking himself just to help them out with their symptoms
 
Riceball said:
I disagree, I don't think that Carol did it out of self-preservation, I think that she honestly felt that it was something that needed to be done for the greater good of the group as a whole.
Click to expand...

When Shane and Otis were trying to escape the walkers, Shane honestly felt that shooting Otis in the leg to slow him down so he could escape was something that needed to be done for the greater good of the group as a whole. If they both died there, he'd have not gotten the medical equipment back to Carl too.

Carol and Shane are no different. They chose to murder other people to further their own survival, no matter how you rationalize it.
 
I call total bs on dumping carol for the moody mongaloid. and double no triple B.S. on the zombies hording up on the fence a few episodes ago and damn near tearing it down stick them in the head .I guess if I was there I would have a full time job on the fence , I mean what else are you gonna do everybody setting around telling stories and taking naps . if any of them wanted to put in a little effort they could push out dig trenches the zombies would fall into when it starts getting full burn them down and wait for others to fall in they had time to make a steel door thingy in the entrance . seriously I would just move into one of the towers and if im awake and there is a zombie on the fence stick . wake up in the middle of the night to **** uh oh a few dozen zombies on the fence guess what stick stick stick stick stick stick stick stick it is not rocket science . I mean the zombie rick sees with the contagion he saw over at least a two day period and I belief it was three . wtf . what part of don't let them horde up on the fence do they not understand , while they are assigning duty's and carol and Darrell were discussing ' a lot more came in over night " and what there going to do about it my fat ass is already on the fence line stick stick stick stick stick stick stick stick " sorry anyway and yeah if carol was gonna go the council should make that call besides maybe rick imagined her confession lol. man just when I thought grimes jr was finally understanding the rules of the new world they get all huffy with him for shooting that kid hey he did not surrender in a timely manner and ******** it there are zombies out here he aint got time to mess with prisoners anyway .
 
Kerr Avon said:
Did you not watch the show? Rick isn't going to lie to the rest of the group. If he did, and it ever came out, his credibility would be shot. Carol didn't really deserve any protection at that point from him.
Click to expand...

Yeah. They've already shown that song-and-dance before (the group doubting Rick as a leader after the attack on the farm, primarily because he didn't tell them about what Jenner told him at the CDC).


mistymills said:
But the council isn't real. THIS IS A RICKOCRACY! :)
Click to expand...

That's RICKTATORSHIP. :)
 
Prediction: Carol will end up saving the Daryl group as their vehicle is busted/out of fuel, thats why she has a wagon.
 
For being such a crucial character and one that's been there from the start, I just can't see them writing her off without giving her some sort of definitive ending. It's not like it's your everyday show where they can just drive off to a new city, to start a new life. It's literally you live or you die. I'd love for her to have an ending like in the comics but I think she's too strong now for that.

I have a feeling that she'll come back at some point.
 
I believe one of two things will happen with Carol... She will run into the rest of the group (Daryl, Tyrese, Michonne, Bob) and help them get out of some mess (as robstyle already mentioned a few posts up) or she will run into the Governor and his goons. I don't think either situation will end well for her
 
That little girl has the missing knife and is going to go Shankapotomus on the infected. Good game Hershel, but I think your toast.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

rocketeer25
Halloween 2024! What are your must watch scary movies?
Replies
12
Views
1,903
TheWolfhound
TheWolfhound
Rummers20820
Superman 2025 suit thread
Replies
10
Views
2,008
masterjedi322
masterjedi322
asalaw
New ST:TOS Fan Film WIP Thread
2 3
Replies
54
Views
1,563
joberg
joberg
TheMechanic
Prop Store Walking Dead auction
Replies
1
Views
727
20mbie
2
Carlgrimes
Looking for Most Accurate Carl Grimes Flannel from Season 7, Episode 7 of The Walking Dead
Replies
4
Views
1,422
areyoukiddingme
areyoukiddingme
Back
Top