JPH
Sr Member
I don't disagree as this is how it's presented. It cuts to another problem I have with the prequels which is the portrayal of the Jedi Order (as PoopaPapaPalps describes in his upcoming post). I think it was a mistake to portray the Jedi as so absurdly rigid in their lifestyle. I'll admit it helps drive Anakin's antagonism but it's at the cost of making the Jedi look like the bad guys. Anakin should be the bad guy.
My issue is the reinforcement of the idea of circumstance being the ultimate deciding factor in one's fate. I certainly am not discounting that circumstance plays a role but if that's going to be the main factor for why someone turns evil, it becomes a "luck of the draw" scenario rather than a matter of succumbing to one's own failings.
...but it doesn't make the jedi the bad guys.
Anakin gets used by the bad guy. Anakin agreed to the situation, then wanted everyone else to fulfill their obligations while he does what he wants. As a kid he didn't know what he was getting into, but then he should have left the jedi properly instead of knowingly lying to them. Qui Gon said he was the Chosen, did he *make* Anakin the chosen or was it really some prophecy coming true...prolly a little of both
Someone who is evil will make that assertion that the jedi look like the bad guys, but that is because that is what evil does, lie. It is the person who rapes or murders and tortures, all while screaming "it wasn't me," or "I have rights!" rights when caught!
And they will prey on anyone dumb enough to give them a chance.
And yes, people change, but he's gotta stop to killing people (or kill the right one) for that to be believable
Last edited: