The simplest way I can say how I feel about BoBF (so far) and The Mandalorian is that it's fun to see new SW material, characters and locations mixed-in with OT characters and locations. That's what I've wanted since I was a kid, watching ESB when it originally came out. I wanted to watch stories with Stormtroopers, and Bounty Hunters, and the Empire, and new spaceships & robots, and good & bad characters fighting for what they believe in. And these shows offer some of that.
Until a few years ago I never imagined we'd have a weekly live action Star Wars TV show with film-quality visuals, so I do appreciate them a lot.
But setting my lifelong SW addiction aside for a minute, my honest criticism is that except for occasional moments, I don't believe the shows are any good. They look good, there's great material in there for quick 1-minute teasers, but I find most of it dull. The first episode of BoBF was no exception.
I find a lot of the directing to be flat-out bad, the writing and performances are weak at best, the staging and pacing are for the most part under-developed, and the scoring is forgettable. I was hoping BoBF would kick off by demonstrating a step up in quality, being from the 2-season Mando team, but it didn't. Fun to watch, not to rewatch. All potential - no substantial delivery.