Analyzer
Master Member
I love the part when he points out this guy as a guard, and how does he except to grab his gun
Star Wars Ahsoka (tv series)
- Thread starter ghostryder
- Start date
I love the part when he points out this guy as a guard, and how does he except to grab his gun
Analyzer
Master Member
At least a couple more scenes than that
The Darth Maul surveillance scene on Tatooine
It also felt like the whale scene and space fight scene evoked both the Asteroid chase scene in ESB and the escape from the Death Star scene in a New Hope with the music as well as some of the shots
Lightning
Master Member
The helmets aren't a problem, the Jedi version doesn't resemble Luke's helmet at all. Its the training remote thats the problem, even in ANH taken alone. Why is there one on the falcon, and what is it's non Jedi purpose? Is this a common thing to use for blaster target practice? You put your blaster on low power and try to hit the remote without getting hit yourself?
According to the NPR Radio Drama (which is now non-canon but still amazing), that's exactly the case. Solo uses the remote for target practice and evasion. That drama was written by Brian Daley, and he had a huge influence on Star Wars lore in the late 80s/early 90s.
“IT’S A CAN’T!!!” (Hold a gun)
I would like to think it was that Obi-Wan had done this for Anakin (and later Anakin's son Luke), and so Anakin did this face shield/blast shield routine with Ahsoka, and so she does it with Sabine.
After you watch this, consider that I (as a young lad) sat in a dark theater in 1977 watching Star Wars for the first time. When Vader slashed through Obi-Wan, then Obi-wan "vanished" I GUESS that I thought he vaporized from the saber... like, that's just what would happen.
Jaitea
Master Member
Yeah but the brief training that Ben gave Luke was to try & convince him that there was a 'Force' & it was within him,....to shut his eyes & let the Force guide him,....a first intro to the Force
But now the helmet that they can't see what's going on is essential training, all part of it,....
I thought the remote was a security device that Han had, like a drone, something that you can use to practice shooting, but also leave it to roam the ship when its empty
J
kalkamel
Master Member
Can you imagine how many Younglings perished on Day 1 of Lightsaber 101 with everyone slashing aimlessly left and right with their blast visors down...
Analyzer
Master Member
I think the most valid points it brings up is the difference in directing cartoons vs live action and that not translating well
I also will not be able to unsee the arm crossing stuff now. Maybe turn it into a drinking game every time one of the characters crosses their arms?
I also will not be able to unsee the arm crossing stuff now. Maybe turn it into a drinking game every time one of the characters crosses their arms?
Definetly not a show for everyone. But I stay away from rant videos like that one. It's Star Wars and some times its good some times its bad... its ok to criticize and complain but when you start to hate something, maybe you should go watch something else instead?. Like this thread is more of a bashing the show than discussing its story. Im out.
That's what happens... Lots of "I don't like this"-type, opinion-based nitpicks, but genuine criticism is few & far between.
I also don't get making the death knell declarations when you're 2-3 chapters into an 8-10 chapter book. I know that both WandaVision & Moon Knight were crapped on when they started, but both turned into probably the best storytelling in recent MARVEL.
I get it though... I held out how 6 for BoBF until the last episode, THEN I decided they'd dropped the ball with the opportunity.
I also don't get making the death knell declarations when you're 2-3 chapters into an 8-10 chapter book. I know that both WandaVision & Moon Knight were crapped on when they started, but both turned into probably the best storytelling in recent MARVEL.
I get it though... I held out how 6 for BoBF until the last episode, THEN I decided they'd dropped the ball with the opportunity.
Well said. I’m not interested in rant videos either. Sadly, so many exist because outrage sells better than thoughtful analysis. It’s much easier to do too.
It’s definitely not for everyone, and I had a lot of criticism early on, but have warmed up to it since then and hope it continues. So I am definitely open to discussing the show good or bad, but when it gets just hateful, I’m not interested in participating.
Jaitea
Master Member
I'm not a big fan of Rant Videos either, just found that Robot Head video to be exactly in tune to how I see this show
Plus, he's pretty humourous
J
Last edited:
Or clothesBecause women aren't known for changing their hair style.
Analyzer
Master Member
Because women aren't known for changing their hair style.
I think the age thing is the continuity. Mon Mothma is looking older in the ROTJ one then she did in Rogue One and ROTS, but in the Andor and Ahsoka she looks the same
in Ahsoka, she should looks at least what, like 30 years older from the Revenge of the Sith time frame, but in Ashoka she doesn't look a day older than Andor/Rogue one
i.e. I can see a natural age progression from ROTS to R1 to ROTJ
Andor and Ahsoka seems the oddity, with Ashoka being really off
Lightning
Master Member
Bacta facelift, couldn't get one between R1 and ROTJ, but she was under a lot of stress.
Similar threads
