Kerr Avon
Master Member
Kirk is less a womanizer and more of a romantic - about everything - his passions were contagious which is why his crew is so damn loyal. Orci and Kurtzman pen these films like fanfic ( and I've read better fanfic).---
Plus the REAL Kirk was an intelligent, educated man. He could quote philosophers, make parallels in history, strategize.
This Kirk? He's a punk who's every action is based on 'instinct' which sorry, is just not enough when you have the lives of hundreds of crew members in the balance, not to mention worlds. I doubt he's ever picked up a book.