ST TOS movie era - who makes the most accurate Captain rank pin?

[BlueSaber]

I see 3 versions. The one I think made by Hollywood pins in the 80s/90s that is 3" long

then there are two that are 2.5" long - one sold on roddenberry.com and one sold on/by Anovos.

It seems like the Roddenberry one was made the same was as the originals and the Anovos one seems to be made from scratch?

https://shop.roddenberry.com/products/captain-rank-pin?variant=20399475654

https://www.anovos.com/products/star-trek-the-original-series-movie-era-captain-rank-pin

 

[Too Much Garlic]

If you are going for the most accurate you should probably go with the Roddenberry one, as that's described as being made the way the originals were made. The Anovos one is idealized.

 

[BlueSaber]

Is the one from Roddenberry curved? How about the chest badge? Also what is the width of the screen accurate movie badge? I just got a Hollywood pins one and it’s 2 13/16” and 1 3/4” high which is smaller than I thought it would be

 

[DB537]

Is the one from Roddenberry curved? How about the chest badge? Also what is the width of the screen accurate movie badge? I just got a Hollywood pins one and it’s 2 13/16” and 1 3/4” high which is smaller than I thought it would be

The Captain pin is slightly curved and it's 2.5" x 3/4". The metal is not flimsy but it is just thin enough that you could carefully reshape it if you need to.
Both of the Captain pins on the uniform are the same size. The chest insignia badge is approximately 3" wide x 2" high.

 

[BlueSaber]

Did you bend yours to match the movies?

Did anyone else think the chest badge was much bigger until they saw it in person?