Space Above & Beyond possible reboot from Disney (I know, but...)

Sluis Van Shipyards

Legendary Member
RPF PREMIUM MEMBER
I just saw this video on Youtube that says Disney is looking at doing a reboot of Space Above & Beyond with one or both of the original creators. I'm cautiously optimistic because it's Disney, but I would love to see what they could do with this show in 2023! I really loved this show because it reminded me a little bit of the Wing Commander PC games.

 
It might be interesting. If they did a reboot, I hope they get rid of the silly concept of the Marines in the show being both grunts and fighter pilots. Even if the Corps does say that every Marine is a rfifleman first, that doesn't mean that the Corps is going to take a group of very expensive, and tightly trained aviators, hand them all rifles, and tell them to go take a hill. They wouldn't even do that with a bunch of cooks, mechanics, and clerks because we already have grunts to do grunt type jobs.
 
Last edited:
Yeah I hope they split it up this time. Have the pilots and another set of infantry or specops that would do ground missions. That would mean more actors, but it would just depend on how much money they want to spend on this. Another thing they could do is have more pilots then a couple main cast as infantry. The infantry guys would just have a bunch of randoms who you would never know and they would have the main guys do the talking. Sort of how on Stargate they would occasionally show another SG team with a known actor (like Adam Baldwin) leading the team which was just made up of extras.
 
Don't know if they can improve on the Hammerhead fighters, but of course they will try. Hope they actually do improve the Chig fighters. Never liked them much. And being Disney, we can all imagine what they'll do with the concept of In Vitroes. We'll see, if it gets made. I like the show, but don't love it. So if Disney does their usual thing, I won't be at all perturbed, ; )

Do love the Hammerhead, and Kristen Cloke, ooh la la, ; )

DyRrNtLX0AA38sY.jpg


310285.jpg
 
One simple thing they could do to improve the Hammerhead would be to fix the canopy and make it a proper bubble canopy to allow the pilot to actually see behind them. Granted that in space you're probably going to be relying on sensors more than using just your eyes, but if things got hairy and up close, it sure would be nice to be able to actually see behind you. This is something that a lot of sci-fi fighter designers make, they make these cool looking fighters with crappy all-around visibility, Star Wars is especially guilty of this.
 
It might be interesting. If they did reboot, I hope they get rid of the silly concept of the Marines in the show being both grunts and fighter pilots. Even if the Corps does say that every Marine first, that doesn't mean that the Corps is going to take a group of very expensive, and tightly trained aviators, hand them all rifles, and tell them to go take a hill. They wouldn't even do that with a bunch of cooks, mechanics, and clerks because we already have grunts to do grunt type jobs.
I don't how long they did it for but during the Vietnam War they wanted their pilots to have experience on the ground since for the most part they were tasked with ground support.
 
One simple thing they could do to improve the Hammerhead would be to fix the canopy and make it a proper bubble canopy to allow the pilot to actually see behind them. Granted that in space you're probably going to be relying on sensors more than using just your eyes, but if things got hairy and up close, it sure would be nice to be able to actually see behind you. This is something that a lot of sci-fi fighter designers make, they make these cool looking fighters with crappy all-around visibility, Star Wars is especially guilty of this.
So which ship, from which series do you like the most? Most practical? Should the pilot be flying as unencumbered as possible or in a space suit?
 
I don't how long they did it for but during the Vietnam War they wanted their pilots to have experience on the ground since for the most part they were tasked with ground support.
All Marine officers, regardless of MOS, do go through The Basic School after OCS where they learn how to lead an infantry platoon, it's the officer equivalent to MCT (Marine Combat Training) for enlisted Marines. However, to the best of my knowledge, this never meant that Marine pilots would do a tour as an infantry officer. What they would sometimes get assigned to would be FAC (Forward Air Controller) duty because, as pilots, they would be better able to communicate with their fellow pilots when directing them in on ground attack runs because they'd know the best ways in and out of a target zone and what obstacles or dangers to look out for. But I don't know if the Corps still does this, not with the advent of the JTAC. With JTACs, who are, from what I understand, enlisted specialists, I'm not sure that FACs are deployed by either the Air Force or the Marines anymore.
 
Last edited:
So which ship, from which series do you like the most? Most practical? Should the pilot be flying as unencumbered as possible or in a space suit?
For pure realism, the B5 Star Fury can't be beat. But for a WWII style dogfight, the best that I can recall seeing is the X-Wing. It's not too wide like an A-Wing so you can see below you without having to angle your fighter, and it actually has some rearward visibility, if a bit restricted.
 
I thought it was an ok show, but there were several problems.

First of all, the casting. Morgan Weisser, the main protagonist, had a bit of a baby pouty face, and his role reminded me of John-Boy Walton in space. Secondly, the writing sucked. All I can remember is just about the only line they gave James Morrison was, "It's too hot!" which he spouted with an inflection like a cough, whenever the generals asked if they could send the troops down. Thirdly, the CGI even for the time was terrible, and the designs, other than the Hammerhead Fighter, looked like they were limited in the amount of polygons. No imagination, and most designs were squarish. In my opinion, any good sci-fi show should have ship designs that are well thought out and cool looking to get people interested in the show. Proof...Mandalorian Razor Crest.

TazMan2000
 
I thought it was an ok show, but there were several problems.

First of all, the casting. Morgan Weisser, the main protagonist, had a bit of a baby pouty face, and his role reminded me of John-Boy Walton in space. Secondly, the writing sucked. All I can remember is just about the only line they gave James Morrison was, "It's too hot!" which he spouted with an inflection like a cough, whenever the generals asked if they could send the troops down. Thirdly, the CGI even for the time was terrible, and the designs, other than the Hammerhead Fighter, looked like they were limited in the amount of polygons. No imagination, and most designs were squarish. In my opinion, any good sci-fi show should have ship designs that are well thought out and cool looking to get people interested in the show. Proof...Mandalorian Razor Crest.

TazMan2000
I actually likeJohn Boy in space

 
I just saw this video on Youtube that says Disney is looking at doing a reboot of Space Above & Beyond with one or both of the original creators. I'm cautiously optimistic because it's Disney, but I would love to see what they could do with this show in 2023! I really loved this show because it reminded me a little bit of the Wing Commander PC games.

I love this since it came out and watch it to this day. I hope someone picks it up and runs with it. Please not like Galactica. They ruined it with reboot. Also, they could run 2 different storylines if they would in reality use Marines as pilots and grunts similar to the sci-fi show StarShip Troopers.
 
I love this since it came out and watch it to this day. I hope someone picks it up and runs with it. Please not like Galactica. They ruined it with reboot. Also, they could run 2 different storylines if they would in reality use Marines as pilots and grunts similar to the sci-fi show StarShip Troopers.
Better to have two different sets of characters or just have the cast be either pilots or grunts, not both. The whole idea of pilots who double as gunts simply because the Marine Corps says that every Marine is a rifleman first is just plain stupid. Aside from that it would be horribly expensive to have a grunt squad made up entirely of officers who are also trained fighter pilots, they would also suck at both of their jobs when compared to dedicated pilots and dedicated grunts. Unless they trained practically 24-7 there's not enough time for them to become truly proficient either in the sky or on the ground since they'd be splitting their training time between the two.
 

Your message may be considered spam for the following reasons:

If you wish to reply despite these issues, check the box below before replying.
Be aware that malicious compliance may result in more severe penalties.
Back
Top