Gary Kerr: “This is either the real McCoy, of the best fake I’ve ever seen”.
Interestingly, that’s what Greg Jein said about the forged auction phaser, back in 2021.
That being said, I also noticed the difference in the secondary hull windows. But far too many other tells and unique details line up with the real model:
* The shape of the linear accelerator/bolt cover on the rear saucer.
* The pilot hull color peeking out where the registry decals have peeled off.
* The placement and spacing of the saucer registry decals (with that very narrow gap between “U.S.S.” and “Enterprise”).
* The overall hull color, which matches vintage photos of the 11-footer.
* The size, placement, and red pinstripe thickness of the markings on the upper saucer,,as well as the circles inside the yellow rectangles on either side of the bolt cover.
* The damage on the copper rings behind the sensor dish on the secondary hull.
* The specific shape of the saucer, which is flatter on both top and bottom than the 11-footer.
* The size, shape, and placement of the window decals (alside from the aforementioned discrepancies on the lower saucer).
* The missing hangar doors.
* The colors of the impulse engines, nacelle pylon vents, and nacelle endcaps, which are different than the 11-footer.
* The size, shape, wood grain, and flexible mounting pole of the display base.
Very few people would be able to replicate the model so accurately and in so much detail, I think. David Shaw is the only person I know of who actually tried (several times) to build replicas (initially by modifying the 22-inch AMT kit, and later by scratchbuilding a 1:1 replica) and also make accurate blueprints.
If someone wanted to put together a forgery to sell at auction, I suspect they wouldn’t have gone to this much trouble and detail. More likely they’d just replicate the 1/350 Polar Lights model (which is based on the 11-footer, of course) in wood.
And, as noted, if this was a scam, it surely wouldn’t have popped up on eBay for a mere $1,000. It would have gone through Studio Auctions with the rest of the fakes, or if someone at Heritage had taken another bribe.
Someone didn’t know what they had, and threw it up on eBay. I’m just glad people were paying attention.