Obi grenade

Dewy

Well-Known Member
Originally posted by Avalon X+Jan 20 2006, 07:50 PM--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(Avalon X @ Jan 20 2006, 07:50 PM)</div>
<!--QuoteBegin-franz bolo
@Jan 21 2006, 12:42 AM
Didn't the Gavidoc emitter have that type of piece?

FB
[snapback]1164128[/snapback]​
Not sure about that, but I do know that was on the real prop (shown in the Chronicles pic). It was detached from the end of the rod that screwed into the end of the grenade. It essentially holds the emitter in place....
[snapback]1164137[/snapback]​
[/b]
Can we see pics of this? Last I had heard all the Obi experts were still in a toss up as to what was in there.
 

franz bolo

Sr Member
I got this image somewhere. Is this the same type of piece?



If the owner doesn't want it up I'll take it down.

FB
 

Banquo Fett

Well-Known Member
Originally posted by Dewy+Jan 21 2006, 01:25 AM--><div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(Dewy @ Jan 21 2006, 01:25 AM)</div>
Originally posted by Avalon X@Jan 20 2006, 07:50 PM
<!--QuoteBegin-franz bolo
@Jan 21 2006, 12:42 AM
Didn't the Gavidoc emitter have that type of piece?

FB
[snapback]1164128[/snapback]​


Not sure about that, but I do know that was on the real prop (shown in the Chronicles pic). It was detached from the end of the rod that screwed into the end of the grenade. It essentially holds the emitter in place....
[snapback]1164137[/snapback]​
Can we see pics of this? Last I had heard all the Obi experts were still in a toss up as to what was in there.
[snapback]1164160[/snapback]​
[/b]
My bad, I thought this was totally confirmed.

I looked at pics I have, and I could have sworn someone here lightened the Chronicles pic to the degree that you could see in the emitter, but I don't have it. Maybe someone else does.

Anyway, it seems logical that this would be inside the emitter, since the Derwent piece is hollow like a bell. This piece I am seeking pins it to the end of the grenade with male/female threaded parts.
 

lesternessman

Well-Known Member
Originally posted by franz bolo@Jan 20 2006, 09:35 PM
I got this image somewhere. Is this the same type of piece?



If the owner doesn't want it up I'll take it down.

FB
[snapback]1164162[/snapback]​

that's a pic of Roman's emitter..
 

Serafino

Sr Member
Here's a better look at the piece in question, on an original grenade:



But IMO there is no evidence that that piece was inside the emitter in the Chronicles pic, and screen caps show that it was definitely NOT in the emitter during certain parts of production.

There was once a theory put forward about some blobs matching hole positions, but in fact they don't match the right hole positions if you test it out photographically, and other features contradict the idea as well. If I can dig up my relevant pics I will post one.

Anyway, this piece is super easy to make, any amateur with a lathe can do one for you, or if you're clever with a drill press and have a pretty sturdy one you can make one yourself.

Ah, here's one. The red line points out that the grey 'blob' (sometimes taken to be 'solder' such as sometimes appears on the 'barrel clip base') actually continues way beyond the place where the clip base would be, and could easily be an angled streak on the inside of a hollow cylinder.



Here's an analysis of this issue I did before we had screen caps from the DVDs. Elipses (circles in perspective) with their centers marked are used to show approximate positions along the length of the saber of various features. Despite the rough nature of the analysis, the 'hole' feature inside the emitter is clearly deep in the emitter:



Documentary footage shows Alec Guinness holding the prop right before a prop man switches it for a bladed stunt for this scene where he turns on the saber, so this is the hero prop.
 

Dewy

Well-Known Member
Originally posted by Avalon X@Jan 21 2006, 12:15 AM
Wow this is all news to me, thanks for this info guys.
[snapback]1164286[/snapback]​
With the speed that all the discoveries were/are being made it's pretty hard to keep up. :) I know I got seriously lost when the derwent discovery came up.

Thanks Serafino, I had never seen the photographic evidence and I too thought it would make sense to have that piece in there, but I guess now we more or less know.
 

Romans Empire

Master Member
RPF PREMIUM MEMBER
Originally posted by franz bolo@Jan 21 2006, 01:35 AM
If the owner doesn't want it up I'll take it down.


[snapback]1164162[/snapback]​
I don't mind.

But if these are floating around out there in cyberspace, maybe I should watermark them so people know where they come from... ;)
 
Top