lonepigeon
Master Member
The whole reason that thread existed in the fist place was because of MR.
Remember it was MoffEaton who started it. Lucasfilm needed more convincing that the parts were there. In the end the decision was split among many involved (here, MR, LFL) so the compromise of removable sight pieces was made.
I still firmly believe my final conclusions in that thread. There's more than enough evidence to prove the antenna piece was there (one not two) but I believe where Gabe and I differ is how we would deal with it on a replica. I lean towards making it the way it was originally built with both antennas intact where as Gabe would rather leave it off completely even though 3/5th's of the assembly was still on the prop for most, if not all of filming (depending on when Chronicles pics were taken).
Remember it was MoffEaton who started it. Lucasfilm needed more convincing that the parts were there. In the end the decision was split among many involved (here, MR, LFL) so the compromise of removable sight pieces was made.
I still firmly believe my final conclusions in that thread. There's more than enough evidence to prove the antenna piece was there (one not two) but I believe where Gabe and I differ is how we would deal with it on a replica. I lean towards making it the way it was originally built with both antennas intact where as Gabe would rather leave it off completely even though 3/5th's of the assembly was still on the prop for most, if not all of filming (depending on when Chronicles pics were taken).