Millennium FX Dr Who Sonic Screwdriver

Status
Not open for further replies.
How many people on this board are having 1 part tarnish on there sonic?? I can not answer that the same alu was used on all of them... And if I hear one more person go on about the head being dia cast I think I will go mad.. ;)

The heads were cnc machined then deburred in a rumbler!!
The only reason I would say its changing colouer is its being handled a lot!

If you want to clean it up use those scotch bright you can brighten up the whole sonic!!

Russ
 
I've never once said it was die cast. In fact I said I know nothing about machining to tell the difference. I just wanted to know why mine was tarnishing and looked different then the rest of the metal. Mine stays mostly in the box it shipped in and comes out once every few months.

Thank you again for the scotchbrite. I'll try and fine some here in town and give it a go.
 
Is there a way of polishing up the inside of the head? Scotchbrite would probably only polish up the outside but the inside will still look dull and tarnished.
 
I have one of the earlier ones and it looks exactly like the day I got it. Haven't really handled that part at all, though.
 
Out of curiosity, I looked at ours and it does look duller now. Hasn't been touched since the day it was bought, just sitting on a shelf.
 
umm you do know that you don't know what you're talking about, right?

Actually, I saw a question posted on another board (GallifreyBase, I think) that pointed out (with screenshots) that they'd never seen Tennant use the yellow/gold/straw/whatever one and I've been going through each episode trying to find it... so far, to no avail. If you can grab any screenshots of that one (or can just point me at an episode) I'd really appreciate it. The show isn't nearly as fun to watch when you're just getting ready to go fram by frame every time he reaches into his jacket!
 
Actually, I saw a question posted on another board (GallifreyBase, I think) that pointed out (with screenshots) that they'd never seen Tennant use the yellow/gold/straw/whatever one and I've been going through each episode trying to find it... so far, to no avail. If you can grab any screenshots of that one (or can just point me at an episode) I'd really appreciate it. The show isn't nearly as fun to watch when you're just getting ready to go fram by frame every time he reaches into his jacket!

Apparently CT has already gone through all the episodes on DVD and hasn't seen the straw colored sonics used by DT at all. Just the grey ones. Read his latest blog. It's a pretty interesting revelation to be honest.

As for going frame by frame everytime the Doc reaches into his pocket ... that's exactly what I've been doing for Doctor 11. Been frame by framing every single episode in 720p and getting the best screen shots and all the details. I even frame by framed the Jonathan Ross show. It really isn't very much fun at all. Got loads of awesome screenshots though :D
 
Last edited:
Yea, the frame by framing (and this hobby in general) stopped being fun for me when it all became about proving you're right and everyone else is wrong. Who costuming has become a cess pool, which is why I'm taking a break. I don't really expect it to get any better, but maybe not thinking about it for a month will allow me to declench enough to never care again when I come back. There are people that ruined this show for me, and their lackeys drove it into the ground.
 
Last edited:
Hey, man... I'm not trying to stir up any feuds or anything. After reading that post on Gallifrey Base (which I now see that you were a contributor to) I started going through to find it for my own curiosity. I see that the same post prompted CT to do the same.

I just looked closely at Turn Left and it looks a lot more like a cream color to me, under night setting lighting, but I could be wrong. The lighting in that scene would be inconclusive no matter what color the thing were.

I mean, I'm not talking about the ridge shape or the spacing on the windows of the emitter head or some tiny detail that only the most eagle-eyed RPFer would notice... I'm talking about the color of a good 70% of the piece. And this is the place to come for these answers. I addressed you because you flat-out told someone they didn't know what they were talking about when they mentioned the color. I assumed that meant that you had some hard evidence to the contrary, because you seem to be a generally nice and helpful guy.
Now, I'll happily go through looking for a scene where I can conclusively tell that the sonic is Gold if you don't have any well-lit examples that you can offer, because I'm not claiming to be or trying to prove that I am right about anything. Nor am I trying to prove anyone wrong. I'm looking for the truth.

So far, none of the shots I've seen can be chalked up to lighting alone, because the sonic is often in the same shot as brown and blue (or blue and rust) material who's color is very familiar to us all and it looks fine.

If the gold was used, I'll find it. At the moment, if given the choice, I'd definitely go with purchasing a gray one.
 
Sorry, no intent to bait, I just thought it looked like more of a pen light. Afterall, it's re-design did drastically depart from the original design of the earlier doctors. That's no reflection on the guys who made the MFX version. I wish I could afford it.
All those involved did a great job to make the MFX SS, just wish it wasn't so scarce and cost prohibitive.

Except for Troughton's... ;) which WAS a penlight :lol
 
Sorry, no intent to bait, I just thought it looked like more of a pen light. Afterall, it's re-design did drastically depart from the original design of the earlier doctors. That's no reflection on the guys who made the MFX version. I wish I could afford it.
All those involved did a great job to make the MFX SS, just wish it wasn't so scarce and cost prohibitive.

No one should call it baiting for you to call it a pen light. In the MFX thread that was 40 pages long and covered from the SDCC prototype reveal all the way through MFX announcing that their license was up, two or three people who purchased the MFX sonic (and were very happy with it) said that it was a very nice pen light once they received it. So call it a pen light all you like. The CT version is a pen light with sound, essentially. It's just the nature of the prop.
 
You guys have another one to build now.

I was watching a early ST-TNG episode and Riker asks the engineer to hand him "that SONIC DRIVER".

Now get with it.
 
It was mentioned in the GB thread that the gold version was used more for publicity shoots than in the episode itself because Tennant preferred handling the stunt prop on screen more than the hero.

It's just an issue of common sense. Why would MFX, who as the license holder and as seen in behind the scenes footage had full access to the props, change the color? It would be a stupid and pointless thing to do. I'm not trying to call anybody out on anything, I'm just sick of this damn debate. People treat this hobby like it's freaking watergate.
 
It's just an issue of common sense. Why would MFX, who as the license holder and as seen in behind the scenes footage had full access to the props, change the color? It would be a stupid and pointless thing to do. I'm not trying to call anybody out on anything, I'm just sick of this damn debate. People treat this hobby like it's freaking watergate.

They have changed the coloour by their own admission of photographic evidence. The sonic they measured with such detail was the gray version.


MFX+Cardiff+Enlarge.jpg


As for the head changing colour. Mine is kept on top of the TV on the stand and has tarnished quite badly. I used autosol to clean it and the tarnish has left a slight pitting. Is there anything I can put on it to stop that, like a clear coat of something?

And a word of warning, try not to polish the edges of the lens when you use this paste as it seems to have a painted surface which this removes :angry
 
Read these.

http://www.therpf.com/showpost.php?p=636889&postcount=87

http://www.therpf.com/showpost.php?p=1004396&postcount=577

I can just predict the next moronic question already "Was Chris involved in the Dr.Who production?"

I do not understand what point those links are proving. Neill has posted pictures of Chris measuring the sonic and it is definately the white version.

4639469360_d34b94a8e6_o.jpg


4638861459_2709d372db.jpg


4638860345_c1f914cf1d.jpg


Find me one screencap of Tennant using the goldy brown version. I have gone through many DVDs since someone questioned it on the Doctor Who forums and it seems they were right, I can not find any evidence of the brown version being used in the programme. I am checking VOTD this evening.

I do not understand why it is OK to question the acuracy of a Master Replicas, EFX, Hollywood Collectables or Sideshow piece, but when anyone questions the MFX sonic, people are pounced on like idiots.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top