I just ordered a
clear glass/lucite Ronson Nordic lighter for $20 + S&H + tax in excellent condition. I'm looking around Etsy and I see the same basic lighter and they want over $300 for it! OMG. You could probably get a Sterling Silver Dunhill for around that much money....
In fact, I've had my eye on a Mini Rolla-Lite in Sterling for some time for $350 (one thing for most sterling lighters is they tend to be in better condition on average (people tend to take better care of nicer things) and often don't need polished as much as they tarnish much slower), but I just can't can't quite see spending that much just because it's solid 92.5% silver alloy instead of plated (pure silver isn't exactly ultra expensive for a few ounces at $23.80 per ounce right now and yet you see some lighters wanting over $1000 compared to $50 just because it's Sterling! It's not GOLD for god's sake.... You'll see tea sets made of Sterling that weigh 5x as much for $100, but a Sterling lighter is worth 20x as much as the silver plated version?

).
Anyway.... Some of the prices online, especially on Etsy are so disconnected from reality it's unbelievable. I don't know how they can sell anything. I guess they're looking for suckers that have no idea what something is worth and are looking for a Christmas gift or something....
I'm looking for a "Colonial" lighter (boy it loves to return "colony" lighters with that search which is a different lighter altogether) and there's someone on eBay that has one in pretty good condition (not sure it's excellent or not; it's certainly no polished) and he's re-listed at least once now and has a
starting bid of $159. It's worth $45-75 in EXCELLENT condition according to my new book. He keeps getting zero bids (no wonder; no one wants to pay 2x-3x what something is actually worth just because someone "feels" like they should get more). I'll just wait for another to appear. Plenty have sold for $40 in the past.
The same is true of the Ronson Tabourette lighter on there right now. I would like one for my collection. I don't want to pay $200 when the book price is $100-200 for "excellent" once again and yet the going price for the past half dozen sold on eBay has been $75-150 (low/high for 1 each and the other 4 were between $80-100 including a really nice leather one that looks far better than the straight line one on there. Plus the button is set wrong (doesn't retract the snuffer all the way so I wonder if there's anything else going on and it'll at least need to be taken apart and adjusted to work correctly). I'm pretty sure even if I offered $130 or even $140 they'd be
insulted too. I've seen it before and usually avoid offering below 25% off the asking price unless I don't care what their response is. Otherwise, I just move on. In general, I find that you really can't convince someone that wants $300 for a $50 lighter that they're asking way way too much. They just tend to not believe you for some reason.
I suppose this belongs in the inconsequential venting thread....