Is our Culture making killers?

Status
Not open for further replies.
But why couldnt films or games inspire them also? I am not on a crusade against film violence, Im just considering something I used to be sure of.
And lawyers love to spew such garbage to get their coward murdering client off the hook and back into society where they can do more ****.
 
Sorry, but this is patently absurd.

While there is certainly no denying that the 24 hour news cycle creates more sensationalism (although the TKDR and Sikh shootings got VASTLY different coverage), the idea that the level of violence never changed but we're just hearing about it now is just kind of silly.

Find me a Columbine in the 1930's. Didn't exist.

I think someone just posted about a 1927 school shooting. 3 years isn't close enough? :behave

Anyway, if you believe there's a causative relationship, I recommend you start a grass roots petition to have all violence forbidden on TV in the People's Republik of Kalifornia. I'm sure that'll help the dwindling movie industry there too, and give me more reason to never go there. ;)
 
Sorry, but this is patently absurd.

While there is certainly no denying that the 24 hour news cycle creates more sensationalism (although the TKDR and Sikh shootings got VASTLY different coverage), the idea that the level of violence never changed but we're just hearing about it now is just kind of silly.

Find me a Columbine in the 1930's. Didn't exist.

Guess you couldn't be bothered to read Unresponsible's post two posts above yours.

To wit, Andrew Kehoe bombed three schools in 1927, killing 45 and injuring at least 58.
 
I think someone just posted about a 1927 school shooting. 3 years isn't close enough? :behave

Anyway, if you believe there's a causative relationship, I recommend you start a grass roots petition to have all violence forbidden on TV in the People's Republik of Kalifornia. I'm sure that'll help the dwindling movie industry there too, and give me more reason to never go there. ;)

Actually friend, you seem to have misread my post, because I was explaining that there IS NOT a causal relationship. Nor am I for the censorship of violence.

Instead of projecting your preconceived notions of Californians on me, perhaps you'd like to deal with the substance of what I wrote.
 
I blame those who oppose neutering these SOBs so they can't breed and spread their insanity. I blame those who allow visitors to these SOBs in jail. I blame those women who write, visit, fall in love, marry, have kids with these SOBs.

However... just on a more serious note. No... I only blame the killer, for being a coward.
 
1920s and no gun was used........

Bath School disaster - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

It's the person.
Populations go up, odds are you will have more incidents.

Sick nutters have been with us since the beginning.
Look all through history and you will find them.
Blaming modern films, weapons, news, books, as if somehow
you change those things nothing bad will happen again is folly.

I blame crappy parents and cultures that embrace actual
criminal violence. (we have lots of that in America)
It's a people problem. Not an object, not a weapon, not a film, not
a law, not a comic book. None of those things are to blame.
 
As population increases does the percentage of the population that commits homicide also increase? How do you quantify the crime rate, total crimes or crimes in relation to population? What's worse, 1 homicide in a population of 10, or 2 in a population of 15? Yes, the latter is more overall, but the former is a lower ratio.

The number of homicides per 100,000 population has decreased in the US over the past 20 years.
 
NHM, Do you mean that they are just plain evil? Mental illness or background then?

I would say 'defective' rather than 'evil' With as many people as we have, there are bound to be defective individuals who can't exist with others peacefully.
 
No the killers, lol.
Unknown, but they surely have some defect, whether it was always there or through bad parenting, who knows. Blaming anything else is just running the killers' errands and excusing their actions and responsibility for said actions. They are to blame. It doesn't matter what inspired them. They took it upon themselves to go out and do the deeds. Blaming and punishing anybody or anything other than those cowardly creeps is just wrong.

That's the first step of censorship and control over the rest of the population just because a few ****tard cowards can't control their sick little urges.
 
As population increases does the percentage of the population that commits homicide also increase?

There is no universal correlation between population size and homicide rate. There are too many other causal factors in play. Some such factors may be per capita income, level of political corruption, stability of government,

How do you quantify the crime rate, total crimes or crimes in relation to population? What's worse, 1 homicide in a population of 10, or 2 in a population of 15? Yes, the latter is more overall, but the former is a lower ratio.

Per capita rates, which for crime statistics, generally uses a sample of 100k, are standard.
 
Just read statistics over the murders in Sweden. Numbers for 1700 - today. It got higher in the middle of 1800, to drop lower again. After 1940 it raised and after 1979 it has been on the same level. Intersting enough it has been close to 100 murders/year since 1980. Since the swedish poulation has grown, killings are less common today.
 
I think that films, books and other media can reinforce anybody's delusions. Just cross-reference Tolkien with the average Black Metal band and you'd think that Lord of the Rings is a neo-nazi pagan handbook that promotes extreme violence, race war and ludicrously overblown music ...

But the fact is that the delusions are often already in place and the violent media only helps to reinforce certain thoughts of violence.
 
Some places it's spiked. Chicago, for instance, is the murder capital. There might be a correlation there, but it's not movies. :behave

Well overall for the country. Too lazy to look up Miami, LA, Detroit, NY, and Chicago specifically.

20 years of decreasing national crime rates. I'll bet there's more media outlets, and with it more media coverage now than 20 years ago.

There I go being absurd again :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top