I'm on the fence about Brotherhood.
Don't be on the fence. Jump off and run away as far as possible. Take the opening narration for instance. This is the
FIRST thing that is said. Here's a hint. The game takes place in the year 2208.
"I was born after the bombs fell"
Note that this character is neither a mutant or a ghoul, so her age would put her around 96 years old in this game AT THE EARLIEST!
And let's not forget about the game's name sake.
Brotherhood of Steel.
"The Brotherhood
is the law, or the closest thing to the law that anyone's seen in a long time."
Yeah, they're lawful in the sense that they don't take part in any village, hub or city that has law issues. Heck, just by expressing an interest in joining the Brotherhood will likely have them sending you to a death trap for laughs! In fact, in Fallout 3, the leader of the Brotherhood of Steel in the Washington area had a lot of his soldiers abandon him just because he took part in aiding the people of the waste land. The Brotherhood of Steel is
NOT a lawful force! They are a self-sustained group who act only to preserve technolog and the progress of humanity. As Lyons says, "It's not hard to figure out how to create a new human, but it is hard to create an A51 Pulse Rifle".
This game SUCKS. It adds nothing to the fallout lore, it contradicts everything and it doesn't have any of the crucial elements that make up a Fallout game.