After Earth (Post-release)

I have no interest in seeing this movie, but I find it entertaining to read the reviews and talkbacks about it. The guy at HitFix had a minor meltdown about the film because people were claiming his "mixed positive" review was a result of being paid off. There's also a rather convincing take from someone who wrote pages of examples about how the film is about Scientology. It's just interesting how controversial and polarizing Shyamalan and his work has become, even in unintentional ways.
 
I have no interest in seeing this movie, but I find it entertaining to read the reviews and talkbacks about it. The guy at HitFix had a minor meltdown about the film because people were claiming his "mixed positive" review was a result of being paid off. There's also a rather convincing take from someone who wrote pages of examples about how the film is about Scientology. It's just interesting how controversial and polarizing Shyamalan and his work has become, even in unintentional ways.

You should read the review on Badass Digest, funniest review I've read in a while.
 
I almost want to see it just to see exactly HOW bad it is...

Ever since the first trailer I viewed for this movie it hasn't looked very good to me. Most of the reviews out there seem to confirm that opinion I had.
 
A lot of the reviews say if it was any other cast and director the story might have made for a really good movie. I agree you cut out the smiths and it looks really good.
 
It's interesting how it's been out for two days and the membership here tends to lean heavily towards scifi, but there are no reviews from anyone that has seen it. Are we all that completely jaded towards Manoj Nelliyatu Shyamalan? I admit I think there's a far better chance I won't like it, based on Shyamalan's track record.

I don't like seeing Will Smith playing similar characters over and over in action roles. I've gotten to the point where I'm just waiting for him to make stupid wisecracks and say, "Ah, Hell no!" Though I understand he carries none of the action in this movie. Jaden Smith was one of the many problems I had with the forgettable The Day the Earth Stood Still remake. Has he gotten any better?
 
I'd say the score on Rotten Tomatoes has pretty well sunk it.At an incredibly low 12% ,its going to struggle to find any box office at all!!!
 
I almost want to see it just to see exactly HOW bad it is...

Ever since the first trailer I viewed for this movie it hasn't looked very good to me. Most of the reviews out there seem to confirm that opinion I had.

This is my attitude as well.
I'll just wait to DL it in a month or so, can't see it lasting in the theatres too long.
I'm totally not interested in any of Will Smith's work, or the family dynasty he's trying to create.
 
I Still cant believe anyone would give that one trick pony money to do a film! :lol
 
Nothing wrong with Will Smith helping his son. It's not like his son is a bad actor, i always found him perfectly fine for the roles, just the story lacking in his movies.

I will go see it with the fiancee.
 
Can we get a copy without him or his son in it? I'd watch that lol. I agree they took a fairly interesting idea for a movie and killed with with what looks like lackluster writing and the fact that it basically just promotes Smith's kid.
 
This movie look alright i guess, only reason I have any interest in it is cause the scenes that took place in the redwoods was filmed about 20 minuets south of my house.
 
Saw this 2 nights ago and had no idea it was a M Night movie, once I saw his name it was a huge facepalm. Lol but it actually wasnt too bad for what it is. Some cheeseyness but overall entertaining. A little more tlc coulda went into designing the alien though. Looked kinda cookie cutter movie monster to me.
 
I won't be seeing this because I agree with the sentiment that it seems Will Smith is forcing his kids (well, the 2 from Jada) down our throats. I used to like Will Smith but it seems his agenda is to make his kids stars. Any movie where Jaden has had a significant role, his father was a Producer and all but The Pursuit of Happyness, Jada his mother was a producer as well.
 
I saw it and the Scientology comparisons are thin at best. Saying that it's based on Scientology teachings because it has things like "Man versus Nature" or that it's got a volcano is so laughingly stupid that the author of that article should probably be lobotomized for making us all dumber for reading his ****.

Now, about the actual movie?

It's ok. It's not great, not terrible. Just nothing to write home about. It's certainly beautifully shot. They tried to invent a new accent for the characters in the movie, but quite frankly that was more distracting than cool. Especially since Will and his son kept falling out of the accent at times. The problem with making a movie like this is that when you essentially have only two actors on screen through 95% of the film, they better be damn fine actors. Will Smith is pretty good, he's had some good roles. Jaden .. Jaden is more there than anything. Just being present on screen is just not enough. The plot is pretty simple, a father/son situation where they are trying to bridge some distance that developed between them over time and after the death the other sibling in the family. It's got some good action moments, some cool scifi tech, but ultimately is pretty mediocre as movies go.

Some problems I had on the plot and setup .. if the Ursa can smell fear in pheromones, why do you need to train people to not be afraid? Just create an entirely self contained and pressurized armor system that prevents the pheromones from escaping into the air. Now your army is entirely invisible to the enemy 100% of the time. The saber weapons are kind of cool, but impractical. I didn't see a single gun the entire movie. Now, you would probably want to keep a saber weapon for hand to hand if it comes to that. BUT, pick up a ****ing gun to shoot the Ursa at a distance to prevent it's size and speed from being such an advantage. Seriously. Even the Ursa was shooting stuff at people more than they shot back.

Definitely catch it on Netflix, or a matinee to a lesser degree.
 
Back
Top