jusdrewit
Sr Member
I really enjoyed some of Adywan's changed, but some, namely the extensive cut of Alderaan's destruction, some random SD scenes, the reordering of the Battle of Yavin, and a few other things bothered me. He seemed to have good intentions to start, but got the Lucas bug and fixed things that didn't need fixing, things that were fine already.
I saw some posts of his where he was updating everyone on his ESB revisted and he was recreating the Hoth hanger with minatures and fake snow etc, and I was just like why...why do you need to reshoot that? The Hoth base is perfect in the original, the set + the matte paintings are what make SW, SW. Granted I haven't seen his ESB video yet, but I didn't get that.
Some fixes I desperately wanted which he fixed some, namely:
-Lukes lightsaber color in ANH really looks bad, and isn't blue but white - was fixed.
-Obi Wans saber flickers and spurts I believe was fixed.
- I actually didn't mind him adding returning gunfire from the Falcon in the escape from the DS battle since we clearly see Han and Luke in the turrets in the interior shots, but maybe just tone it down a wee bit. But I think that was a nice touch
- I also didn't mind the added effect of the MF in hyperspace after they defeat the TIEs as Tarkin clearly states they made the jump to hyperspace and in the original outside the cockpit is just a black starfield. That was nice touch and didn't bother me.
Basically I was I could pick and choose which ones were added lol
I saw some posts of his where he was updating everyone on his ESB revisted and he was recreating the Hoth hanger with minatures and fake snow etc, and I was just like why...why do you need to reshoot that? The Hoth base is perfect in the original, the set + the matte paintings are what make SW, SW. Granted I haven't seen his ESB video yet, but I didn't get that.
Some fixes I desperately wanted which he fixed some, namely:
-Lukes lightsaber color in ANH really looks bad, and isn't blue but white - was fixed.
-Obi Wans saber flickers and spurts I believe was fixed.
- I actually didn't mind him adding returning gunfire from the Falcon in the escape from the DS battle since we clearly see Han and Luke in the turrets in the interior shots, but maybe just tone it down a wee bit. But I think that was a nice touch
- I also didn't mind the added effect of the MF in hyperspace after they defeat the TIEs as Tarkin clearly states they made the jump to hyperspace and in the original outside the cockpit is just a black starfield. That was nice touch and didn't bother me.
Basically I was I could pick and choose which ones were added lol