Space In Vader
Active Member
Still I find out new things about this after all the years.
"The Empire Strikes Back" just a carbon copy of "2001: A Space Odyssey"?
- Thread starter Space In Vader
- Start date
Mottrex
Sr Member
This... Half those side by side shots bare little to no comparisons.. The only real peace was the Ubrikian Landspeeder which was always meant as a nod.
Plus SW shared many a stage crew effects artists but that's it..
YouTube Click bait..
Ehhh a stretch to say the least.
Maybe some pre-production art designers would have been influenced some.
Maybe some pre-production art designers would have been influenced some.
Lord Boron
Sr Member
they do both have rectangles in them. Must be a copy….
I must have missed something the multiple times I've watched each movie...
JediMichael
Master Member
Besides what stuff the Matrix itself copied, how about all the tons of movies that copied the Bullet time effect. Parody or not, that would be a pretty big list.
Oh my gosh—yes! This man is 100% correct!
Why, I remember that scene, right after Han was frozen in carbonite, when the Ughnaut that touched Han’s carbonite slab beat another Ughnaut to death with a bone—just like the monkey in 2001!
It’s just like poetry…it rhymes.
2001 is a Science Fiction film. The Empire Strikes Back is a Space Fantasy film. Two different genres. Seeing similarities between them isn't unrealistic given that they both shared a lot of the same production team. Tonally and narratively to suggest Empire is a copy is absurd.
NakedMoleRat
Master Member
Space 1999, yes.
TESB, no!
Shun the non-believers, SHUUUUUUUNNNNNNN!
TESB, no!
Shun the non-believers, SHUUUUUUUNNNNNNN!
joberg
Legendary Member
Stanley Kubrick tried to stop Space: 1999 with a lawsuit in 1975 because he felt its title was too similar to his 2001: A Space Odyssey. "The deliberate choice of a date only two years away from 2001 is not accidental and harms us," he wrote in one of many frenzied telexes. (Somewhat optimistically, he also predicted the show would be "important" and run for years.) Was he worried people might think the campy rubber-monsters show was a continuation of his ape/fetus acid-trip? Or did he just want a monopoly on titles with "space" and a near-future date? Crazy obsessions like the Space: 1999 lawsuit kept him from finishing several movie projects. (Gizmodo article).
universaljoint
Member
That video was weak. But It's 100% clear that George Lucas was influenced by the style and cinematography, because it was a masterpiece.
And so much that he wanted 2001: ASO visual effects designer Brian Johnson to come on board, but couldn't because he was doing Space:1999...
I'm curious now if Lucas had people who worked on 2001... So much of his team was responsible for taking his vision and turning it into something practical for him. It makes sense that the influences of the past would be in GLs work. Just in general.
But calling it a "carbon copy" is highly subjective to one's definition of what a "carbon copy" is. And Star Wars is not.
Now, is no one going to address that someone is using the term "carbon copy" 24 years into the 21st century? I know what that actually is. But just calling it a copy would suffice. I'm just being a little facetious and poking fun at the use of the old timey term. No malice intended.
And so much that he wanted 2001: ASO visual effects designer Brian Johnson to come on board, but couldn't because he was doing Space:1999...
I'm curious now if Lucas had people who worked on 2001... So much of his team was responsible for taking his vision and turning it into something practical for him. It makes sense that the influences of the past would be in GLs work. Just in general.
But calling it a "carbon copy" is highly subjective to one's definition of what a "carbon copy" is. And Star Wars is not.
Now, is no one going to address that someone is using the term "carbon copy" 24 years into the 21st century? I know what that actually is. But just calling it a copy would suffice. I'm just being a little facetious and poking fun at the use of the old timey term. No malice intended.
Similar threads
