Actually this is contradictory. :behave
No, it's not. I'm pointing out that if a little girl can easily get lost, Darryl himself can end up getting lost too if he goes too far off trail (basic standard in making your way back to a location is to walk back the same path you walked to get out there).
They had a map of the area to base a proper search from.
And do you honestly think Darryl was carrying the only map that the whole group has access to with him? I didn't see him checking a map before attempting to climb the hill the first or second time.
That and a river only flows one direction. The only reason he woudlnt have followed the river to a walk out point is it flows further away from the farm or it is all canyon (which makes no sense given the location) or a waterfall is in the path.
Before you argue this, keep in mind I was a CDF fire fighter for a couple years and have been on many a search and rescue operation in rain, floods, snow, heat, fire and goat feed for a large group of goats that somehow made their own way to the basement of a semi burnt out home to escape a large forest fire. Talk about a major "WTF!" moment with all these devil eyes reflecting at you not knowing what your looking at...
I'm not arguing this. The last time I checked, we were having a calm discussion about this particular topic.
Besides, did you not consider the possibility that he was hoping that the horse was still at the spot at the top of the hill, which is why he was trying so hard to climb up it? With an arrow sticking through you, or even with an arrow hole in you, if the thought there was a possibility that the horse was still in the area of where you were thrown off and possibly be able to easily ride back to the farm, you'd try to climb for it. We find out it wasn't there after he makes it, but before that, there was the possibility of the horse still being there.
In regards to the barn, its another thing that may work in a comic but not in a live setting. The smell alone much less the noise would tip anyone off within minutes. It also furthers the zombiepocalypse makes people into idiots theory in this universe. First thing you do is secure the area and do routine patrols on your surroundings and defenses. So far it doesnt seem they are paying attention to anything not facing directly in front of the house. His farm his rules hasnt meant anything to anyone so that argument is also invalid.
If I recall correctly, Hershel told Rick that he and his people were to stay away from the barn when Rick offered to have his group set up near it (as not to give the impression to them that they were allowed to stay at the farm permanently). In the comics, almost the same thing occurred, when Rick offered to set up his people inside of the barn so that they wouldn't be stuck in the R.V. in the front of the house. Since Rick is trying to get on Hershel's good side, I think he would have made sure that his group would stay away from the barn. And unless you're inside the barn (like Glen was), it's hard to smell something outside of a building from a few yards away, let alone hear anything (using an example from the show, Rick had to scream at the top of his lungs at Andrea for her to hear him from where he stood near Darryl. A small group of zombies moaning and weakling banging against a locked barn door wouldn't be able to be heard from where the house is).
The reason why Hershel's rules haven't been followed is because Rick hasn't forced his group to follow all of them (the only one he's forced so far is the no handling guns on the property, in the beginning, then he let it slide). If I had been Rick, especially since she came so close to killing Darryl and had been told NOT to shoot the rifle before heading out, I would have revoked Andrea's gun privileges. That means she wouldn't have ever touched another gun again unless it was really necessary (I wouldn't care how much she griped about it like she did when Dale wouldn't give her the gun). That would be the only way for her and the others to know that following the rules are important. You have to re-enforce the rules. So far, Rick has allowed things to slide and he hasn't re-enforced them despite giving his word that his group would follow them. This is pretty much setting up a good reason for Hershel turning away the group (where as in the comics, there wasn't much of a reason for Hershel to turn them away until the incident of trying to load in another zombie into the barn).
Since we seem to be going "there", where is the sick and twisted farm hand thats keeping some sex slave zombies? Thats got to be right up there with the first person who looked at a cow teet and thought "I got to get me some of that".
I haven't seen a character like that in the comic in the three volumes I've read thus far (I don't know about anything from Volume 4 on up, so if anyone knows if such a character turns up in the comics, please let me know so that I at least be sure for any kind of future discussions that involve such a topic). And since they're already pushing the boundary with the show as it is with the graphic zombie violence, they're not going to go that far for the show (seriously, if it were HBO or Showtime, they could probably get away with that. But this is AMC we're talking about).