Overall I'm actually still kind of on the fence. As I said, I'll watch next week.
But, just to break it down a little, now that I've had time to think about it:
I like the look. Yes the CGI was cartoony in places, but for TV it was actually pretty good. Overall I think this show looks more like Star Trek than Star Trek does, at least from what we've seen so far. I also like the ship a lot.
It was less funny than I expected, although I did have a couple of genuine laugh moments. But, now that I've seen it, I almost want it to be even less funny than it was. Surprisingly, I liked the strait-up parts more than the comedy and I hope they don't miss out on real potential there. Right now it's lost in between comedy and serious and seems to have some trouble deciding what it is.