Without more information, it's hard to say what's causing it.
From my own casting experience, I noticed that any time I followed the directions on adding pigment to SmoothCast 325 resin, I'd end up with a dripping, not curing mess. When I started adding the pigment after mixing Part A and Part B it came out fine. No idea if its old pigment or what, but just what works for me.
Personally, I avoid using any kind of mixing stick that's made out of wood, I have a metal stick I use and haven't had any problems with resin curing. If it's a small spot on the resin, you can always add a couple coats of superglue over it to seal it up, but if the whole casting is still tacky or dripping resin, then there's something wrong with the process.