crabra comander
Master Member
Which fans? The ones who moan and gripe for any designs they see that are new but ugly? And then gripe more when the films play it safe and keep the same designs?
The films got a ton of new fans, a younger generation as well, so I'm sure that the older fans will either gracefully bow out and let people enjoy these films or continually gripe about TFA in every new Star Wars film they create...:lol
I think we need to just hope this isn't a ESB rehash but also appreciate the fact that, in this universe, there are Walkers...and yes they are impractical, but they are also pretty cool. I mean, who the hell puts AT-AT's on Endor, where the hell did they find room for those things in that forest? I just re-watched ROTJ and it reminded me of the SE ANH when R2-D2 is hiding behind more rocks than was possible for him to enter...:lol George Lucas should have added more trees behind the walker on Endor and a dancing band of CGI monstrositys to top it off :lol
I also think that the Fist Order will establish their dominance and put the Resistance on the ropes, a la ESB. No big deal, just don't have a huge reveal of lineage of Rey's twin brother or have her get her hand sliced
The films got a ton of new fans, a younger generation as well, so I'm sure that the older fans will either gracefully bow out and let people enjoy these films or continually gripe about TFA in every new Star Wars film they create...:lol
I think we need to just hope this isn't a ESB rehash but also appreciate the fact that, in this universe, there are Walkers...and yes they are impractical, but they are also pretty cool. I mean, who the hell puts AT-AT's on Endor, where the hell did they find room for those things in that forest? I just re-watched ROTJ and it reminded me of the SE ANH when R2-D2 is hiding behind more rocks than was possible for him to enter...:lol George Lucas should have added more trees behind the walker on Endor and a dancing band of CGI monstrositys to top it off :lol
I also think that the Fist Order will establish their dominance and put the Resistance on the ropes, a la ESB. No big deal, just don't have a huge reveal of lineage of Rey's twin brother or have her get her hand sliced
You mean the same Bryan who, just weeks from TFA's release, dismissed the growing rehash concerns by labeling them idiotic?
https://www.therpf.com/showthread.php?t=229962&p=3831670&viewfull=1#post3831670
It might have made business sense, but the rest of us are discussing these films in terms of fandom, not financial investment. If there was any intent to appeal to existing fans then choosing to rehash ANH was a miscalculation. Why? Because even TFA's defenders cite that as their biggest criticism.
Last edited: