Darth Lars
Master Member
Re: Star Wars Episode VII
Yes, the music is very "lounge-ish" (for the line to the attraction, I suppose), but I think that he did a pretty good job.
Compare Star Wars (1977) with Superman - I could not tell them apart when I was a kid. Then compare AOTC with some of Harry Potter.
What the fans crave is a movie and a soundtrack that feels like the old trilogy. What is needed of the new composer is to create a replica sound, not bring so much of his own character into it.
Michael Giacchino did the soundtrack for the new Star Tours (Star Wars-themed ride at Disneyland).Actually on that note (Ha! "note") I was hoping that Abrams would bring in Michael Giacchino to take on the score.
Yes, the music is very "lounge-ish" (for the line to the attraction, I suppose), but I think that he did a pretty good job.
Yes. Williams has his periods... The other work he did in the '70s sounds like Star Wars, and the other work he did in the early part of this century sounds like AOTC and ROTS.While still an incredibly talented composer, I think Williams lacks the original touch that he did when scoring the OT.
Compare Star Wars (1977) with Superman - I could not tell them apart when I was a kid. Then compare AOTC with some of Harry Potter.
While I love that soundtrack (it is on my favourite playlist), I don't agree that it would work.The guy that did the soundtrack for SW:TOR comes to mind, whoever he is. As terrible as that game was, he did an outstanding work in that department (that ties in to my point above too). That music sounded more like Star Wars than most of the prequel soundtracks did. IMO.
What the fans crave is a movie and a soundtrack that feels like the old trilogy. What is needed of the new composer is to create a replica sound, not bring so much of his own character into it.