The BTS doc will premiere on Sept 8th.
Started watching this around midnight but fell asleep to it, gotta finish it tonightFood for thought.
Just recently found him. Been getting caught up on past shows.Started watching this around midnight but fell asleep to it, gotta finish it tonight
I’m a huge fan of Michael
Oh man! I bumped into him a long time ago. He was like the first to do videos on restoring toys. He doesn’t do that anymore.. which is a shameJust recently found him. Been getting caught up on past shows.
Him and Armless Vader...Started watching this around midnight but fell asleep to it, gotta finish it tonight
I’m a huge fan of Michael
That's the thing that gets me about this show. The premise, Obi-Wan dealing with the emotional trauma of Anakin's fall, and leaving him to die. That's deep. Obi-Wan having to come back to the Jedi we're more familiar with. Learning from Qui-Gon. Even trying to reach out to Vader. That's a very good premise.
But instead of a physical conflict. Why couldn't Obi-Wan try to reach Vader through the Force. Make the whole show far more cerebral and spiritual. Don't try to give the rematch of the century. It just muddies ANH and ROTS.
That sounds like an interesting book but the nuances of a story like that would be really difficult to pull off in a visual media format.That's the thing that gets me about this show. The premise, Obi-Wan dealing with the emotional trauma of Anakin's fall, and leaving him to die. That's deep. Obi-Wan having to come back to the Jedi we're more familiar with. Learning from Qui-Gon. Even trying to reach out to Vader. That's a very good premise.
But instead of a physical conflict. Why couldn't Obi-Wan try to reach Vader through the Force. Make the whole show far more cerebral and spiritual. Don't try to give the rematch of the century. It just muddies ANH and ROTS.
I like to think if The House of Mouse gave more credit to what audiences want they could easily..That sounds like an interesting book but the nuances of a story like that would be really difficult to pull off in a visual media format.
Star Wars isn't about subtlety, it's about "WOW! Look at THAT!" and "Look what he/she can DO!"... not to dismiss the all powerful nostalgia of "I remember THOSE!".
Lucas created Star Wars as an open rejection of the cynicism and moral ambiguity of his directorial contemporaries. While his aesthetic was grounded in realism with a "used universe" the themes were universal and optimistic. His work stood out because nearly everything around it felt hopeless by comparison. It perfectly balanced the lighthearted adventure with drama that still felt grounded enough for an audience to be emotionally invested, and deftly kept the material from becoming too silly but also not oppressively dark.
Modern audiences tend to think of aspirational heroes like Luke Skywalker as being bland or uninteresting but that's because these modern writers don't know how to write them and our culture appears to have no sense of dignity whatsoever. Heroes by definition are selfless. Without sacrifice, you cannot be a hero. Someone or something, whether literally or metaphorically has to die. As human beings we intrinsically know this and anyone saying otherwise is lying to themselves. Heroism comes at a cost, and that cost is your life, your well being, your wants, your desires, your dreams and sometimes as simple as your own basic needs of food, clothing, and shelter. A real hero is willing to give up these to do the right thing. In fact the more they have to give up, the greater their calling as a hero, and by extension the greater the satisfaction as an audience because we know what they are losing to save others. It's a reflection of the things we often can't do ourselves and we race after it because deep down we know we will never reach it, but we strive after it because it gives up hope that there might be better outside of ourselves.
Our culture and everything in it, is about self and the worship of self, where true heroism is a rejection of self. It doesn't mean that a hero needs to be flawless. Far from it! The difference being that modern "heroes" often start out with every positive trait an audience could want, whether it's strength or intelligence, or wit, and today's writers think that audiences will aspire to those traits. Some audiences crave wish fulfillment and want to live out their power fantasies, but that can only carry a story so far. Had Return of the Jedi been the first Star Wars film, there would be nowhere left for Luke to go as a character. That's why any story with him since has been severely lacking. That film works, only because of the first two films that preceeded it, and the journey Luke traveled to get to that point.
A hero has a flaw, or even multiple flaws, but the story exposes those flaws to the protagonist, and it's their choices, good or bad, that will reveal their true nature as a person. Despite being impatient and angry, Luke, time and again rebels against the temptation to join the dark side and is willing to die rather than give in to evil. In fact as each film goes he nearly does die and the stakes only build as the story progresses, but somehow he overcomes death, often by the help of those around him who are so moved by his selflessness that they choose to act accordingly.
I say all of this to illustrate that those defining characteristics or themes that Lucas baked into the DNA of this series are what made it the mega success it is today and why its endured, and will continue to endure as a film classic. Changing that formula is why any new addition will never feel right, unless handled by skilled writers. I don't need to know how clever the writers are. I don't want to read their power fantasies. I don't want their personal politics or commentary on them. I don't want snarky, know it all protagonists with rotten or boring personalities. I don't want retreads of the same things we've seen, only terribly written versions of them, or scripts that feel like they're written by bots where the raw ingredients of a story are there but combined in the wrong quantities and order to deliver a bland or unappetizing mess.
I want to be inspired by a modern hero. I want to see their struggles and for them to triumph over them not because they outsmarted everyone, not because they were physically stronger, not because they had a superpower, not because they had influence or fame. I want to see a lowly, humble character deal with mounting problems, relatable problems, and choose to set their own needs aside for the good of others, even if it means they might die in the process. This world needs heroes like that. I need heroes like that, because I know I can never be like that, but at least it gives me something to aim for.
2 big reasons.That's the thing that gets me about this show. The premise, Obi-Wan dealing with the emotional trauma of Anakin's fall, and leaving him to die. That's deep. Obi-Wan having to come back to the Jedi we're more familiar with. Learning from Qui-Gon. Even trying to reach out to Vader. That's a very good premise.
But instead of a physical conflict. Why couldn't Obi-Wan try to reach Vader through the Force. Make the whole show far more cerebral and spiritual. Don't try to give the rematch of the century. It just muddies ANH and ROTS.