OK, would it have been over the top to show on the TV Heston in the final scene of the original POTA when he sees the Statue of Liberty? I don't think so.
Yes, that would've been completely ridiculous. As it was, there were a few too many references to the original film.
I liked the movie. Best in the franchise since the original. I'd give it an 8.25 out of 10. The CGI was very impressive much of the time, but appeared transparent other times. Organic beings created with CGI still have a ways to go. The Orangutan was the most realistic CGI ape in the film.
James Franco's acting hasn't impressed me since
Freaks and Geeks. He plays a great high school stoner, but unfortunately, he was terribly miscast as a brainy scientist in this film. It was the least convincing scientist performance since Kelly McGillis in Top Gun. And yet, there's something unoffensive about Franco, so it didn't ruin the movie for me.
I love primates (including wookiees...lol) so I really enjoyed watching Caesar's (and the other apes's) face and body language for one hour and fifty minutes. But as good as the CGI work was for much of the film, I think the practical makeup on General Thade (in Burton's abortion) still ranks as the best-looking ape in the entire catalog of Ape films.
A sign for me loving a film, is if I want to see it again (in the theater). Not sure I want to see this film again until it hits cable. But I did enjoy it.
The Wook
ps~Minor quibble that bothers a primatology nut like me...chimps can't throw spears. Their wrists are fused for knuckle-walking and only bend forward, not backwards.